|
Post by James on Dec 6, 2018 2:15:42 GMT
Live-action only.
1. The Dark Knight 2. Batman (1989) 3. Superman (1978) 4. Batman Returns 5. Wonder Woman 6. Watchmen 7. V for Vendetta 8. Superman II 9. The Dark Knight Rises 10. Batman Begins 11. Man of Steel 12. Justice League 13. Superman Returns 14. Suicide Squad 15. Batman v Superman 16. Green Lantern 17. Batman Forever 18. Superman III 19. Superman IV: The Quest for Peace 20. Batman & Robin
Anyone agree?
|
|
|
Post by politicidal on Dec 6, 2018 3:15:04 GMT
Still hadn't seen either Watchman or V for Vendetta; rectifying that soon. That I've seen:
Batman Begins
The Dark Knight
Superman: The Movie
Wonder Woman
Man of Steel
Superman II
Batman
The Dark Knight Rises
Suicide Squad
Batman Returns
Justice League
Superman Returns
Batman versus Superman
Jonah Hex
Batman Forever
Superman III
Green Lantern
Catwoman
Batman & Robin
|
|
|
Post by HorrorMetal on Dec 6, 2018 3:21:45 GMT
1. Batman 2. The Dark Knight 3. Superman 4. Superman II 5. Batman Returns 6. Batman Begins 7. Watchmen 8. V for Vendetta 9. Wonder Woman 10. Justice League 11. The Dark Knight Rises 12. Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice 13. Man of Steel 14. Superman Returns 15. Jonah Hex 16. Constantine 17. Superman III 18. Green Lantern 19. Batman Forever 20. Superman IV 21. Supergirl 22. Batman & Robin 23. Catwoman
|
|
|
Post by James on Dec 6, 2018 3:22:43 GMT
1. Batman 2. The Dark Knight 3. Superman 4. Superman II 5. Batman Returns 6. Batman Begins 7. Watchmen 8. V for Vendetta 9. Wonder Woman 10. Justice League 11. The Dark Knight Rises 12. Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice 13. Man of Steel 14. Superman Returns 15. Jonah Hex 16. Constantine 17. Superman III 18. Green Lantern 19. Batman Forever 20. Superman IV 21. Supergirl 22. Batman & Robin 23. Catwoman Forgot about Catwoman. I’d place it last as well.
|
|
|
Post by James on Dec 6, 2018 3:23:38 GMT
Still hadn't seen either Watchman or V for Vendetta; rectifying that soon. That I've seen:
Batman Begins
The Dark Knight
Superman: The Movie
Wonder Woman
Man of Steel
Superman II
Batman
The Dark Knight Rises
Suicide Squad
Batman Returns
Justice League
Superman Returns
Batman versus Superman
Jonah Hex
Batman Forever
Superman III
Green Lantern
Catwoman
Batman & Robin
You definitely should see them, politicidal.
|
|
|
Post by Tristan's Journal on Dec 6, 2018 10:02:24 GMT
Wow difficult, especially most of the Batfilms are very close:
1. Watchmen 2. Superman
3. Wonder Woman
4. The Dark Knight Returns (Miller) 5. The Dark Knight 6. Batman v Superman (DirCut) 7. Batman Returns 8. Batman Begins 9. V for Vendetta 10. Batman (1989) 11. Man of Steel 12. The Dark Knight Rises 13. Superman II 14. Justice League 15. Superman Returns 16. Suicide Squad 17. Lego Batman 18. Superman III
19. Batman & Robin (it's so bad it's serviceable) 20. Superman IV: The Quest for Peace 21. Batman Forever 22. Green Lantern (only seen parts of it)
|
|
|
Post by sostie on Dec 7, 2018 1:08:52 GMT
Well if V For Vendetta is being included - a title DC bought, but didn't develop or originally publish - I'll include DC imprints as well
A History of Violence Watchmen The Dark Knight Rises The Dark Knight V for Vendetta Batman Returns Superman II Batman (1989) Superman (1978) RED Road to Perdition The Losers RED 2 Batman Begins Man of Steel Wonder Woman Superman Returns Superman III Batman v Superman Jonah Hex Constantine Suicide Squad Justice League Batman Forever Batman & Robin Catwoman Supergirl Superman IV: The Quest for Peace
|
|
|
Post by James on Dec 7, 2018 1:15:29 GMT
Well if V For Vendetta is being included - a title DC bought, but didn't develop or originally publish - I'll include DC imprints as well Oh, that’s why it doesn’t get talked about as much in the DC lineup. I was wondering.
|
|
|
Post by sostie on Dec 7, 2018 1:22:19 GMT
Well if V For Vendetta is being included - a title DC bought, but didn't develop or originally publish - I'll include DC imprints as well Oh, that’s why it doesn’t get talked about as much in the DC lineup. I was wondering. It was a ongoing story in the British Magazine Warrior. The magazine folded and DC bought the rights to reprint the story published so far as well as the remainder of the story waiting to be published
|
|
|
Post by moviebuffbrad on Dec 7, 2018 2:53:38 GMT
To keep it simple, I'll do all theatrical movies (and thus theatrical cuts).
The Dark Knight V For Vendetta Batman: Mask of the Phantasm Wonder Woman A History of Violence The Lego Batman Movie Road to Perdition Superman II Superman Batman Begins Batman Returns Batman 66 Batman 89 The Dark Knight Rises Justice League Superman Returns Man of Steel Constantine Watchmen Batman Forever Suicide Squad Superman 3 Superman 4 Green Lantern Batman V Superman Batman and Robin
|
|
|
Post by James on Dec 7, 2018 3:14:49 GMT
To keep it simple, I'll do all theatrical movies (and thus theatrical cuts). The Dark Knight V For Vendetta Batman: Mask of the Phantasm Wonder Woman A History of Violence The Lego Batman Movie Road to Perdition Superman II Superman Batman Begins Batman Returns Batman 66 Batman 89 The Dark Knight Rises Justice League Superman Returns Man of Steel Constantine Watchmen Batman Forever Suicide Squad Superman 3 Superman 4Green Lantern Batman V Superman Batman and Robin Ah you finally saw it. Don’t say we didn’t warn you.
|
|
|
Post by moviebuffbrad on Dec 7, 2018 4:09:41 GMT
To keep it simple, I'll do all theatrical movies (and thus theatrical cuts). The Dark Knight V For Vendetta Batman: Mask of the Phantasm Wonder Woman A History of Violence The Lego Batman Movie Road to Perdition Superman II Superman Batman Begins Batman Returns Batman 66 Batman 89 The Dark Knight Rises Justice League Superman Returns Man of Steel Constantine Watchmen Batman Forever Suicide Squad Superman 3 Superman 4Green Lantern Batman V Superman Batman and Robin Ah you finally saw it. Don’t say we didn’t warn you. Hey, you guys told me to watch that sh*t. Terrible effects and some questionable Superman acts aside, I'm surprised I didn't completely hate it, though.
|
|
|
Post by James on Dec 7, 2018 4:12:29 GMT
Ah you finally saw it. Don’t say we didn’t warn you. Hey, you guys told me to watch that sh*t. Terrible effects and some questionable Superman acts aside, I'm surprised I didn't completely hate it, though. I don’t hate it completely either. At least the message is relevant and Reeve still gave it his all.
|
|
|
Post by moviebuffbrad on Dec 7, 2018 4:52:40 GMT
Hey, you guys told me to watch that sh*t. Terrible effects and some questionable Superman acts aside, I'm surprised I didn't completely hate it, though. I don’t hate it completely either. At least the message is relevant and Reeve still gave it his all. Indeed.
|
|
|
Post by charzhino on Dec 7, 2018 9:24:53 GMT
Solid top 10
|
|
|
Post by Rey Kahuka on Dec 7, 2018 17:44:55 GMT
1. The Dark Knight/Batman Begins (9/10) 2. Wonder Woman (8/10) 3. Batman (1989) (7/10) 4. Watchmen (7/10) 5. V For Vendetta (7/10) 6. Batman Returns (6/10) 7. Superman II (6/10) 8. Superman (6/10) 9. Justice League (6/10) 10. BvS (Terrible movie overall, but this version of Bruce is incredible and highly rewatchable) 11. Man of Steel (Not a fan of the disaster porn final act or the poor representation of Jonathan Kent, otherwise a solid flick)
Just a bunch of garbage equally awful in its own way: Superman III Superman IV Superman Returns Supergirl Batman Forever Batman & Robin The Dark Knight Rises Suicide Squad
|
|
|
Post by Grabthar's Hammer on Dec 8, 2018 6:54:15 GMT
1. The Dark Knight 2. Batman Begins 3. Batman Returns 4. Wonder Woman 5. Batman (1989) 6. Watchmen 7. V for Vendetta 8. Superman II 9. Superman (1978) 10. Man of Steel 11. Batman v Superman 12. Constantine 13. Suicide Squad 14. Justice League 15. Batman Forever 16. The Dark Knight Rises 17. Superman Returns 18. Batman & Robin 19. Green Lantern 20. Supergirl 21. Superman IV: The Quest for Peace 22. Superman III 23. Jonah Hex 24. Catwoman 25. Steel
It's difficult for me to rank The Dark Knight Rises. It was such a huge disappointment to me but it still has that top-notch Nolan direction and it's beautifully shot, and I love the interpretation of the Lazarus Pit. But I'd be much more likely to re-watch Batman Forever than TDKR.
Also for Superman Returns, Routh and Sam Huntington are perfect, the airplane scene is gold, but the story was pretty meh.
|
|
|
Post by Skaathar on Dec 9, 2018 0:41:27 GMT
I'm probably one of few people who'd rank Batman Returns and Batman Begins higher than TDK.
|
|
havenless
Sophomore
@havenless
Posts: 715
Likes: 311
|
Post by havenless on Dec 9, 2018 3:20:43 GMT
Mine does fit inline slightly more with the general public, but with a few kinks: GL wasn’t terrible, it was just terribly boring. Forever is easily the worst Batman film, and anyone who doesn’t have Catwoman as the worst comic movie ever needs to watch Catwoman again. Also, I personally don’t think animated features are comparable to live action, as the real thing is such an immersive experience... otherwise Mask of the Phantasm would be very, very high on my list.
22. Catwoman 21. Superman IV 20. Supergirl 19. Batman Forever 18. Superman III 17. Green Lantern 16. Batman & Robin 15. Suicide Squad 14.Justice League 13. Superman Returns 12. Dawn of Justice 11. The Dark Knight Rises 10. V for Vendetta 9. Watchmen 8. Constantine 7. Batman Returns 6. Man of Steel 5. Batman 4. Wonder Woman 3. Superman: The Movie 2. Batman Begins 1. The Dark Knight
|
|
|
Post by James on Dec 9, 2018 11:10:19 GMT
Mine does fit inline slightly more with the general public, but with a few kinks: GL wasn’t terrible, it was just terribly boring. Forever is easily the worst Batman film, and anyone who doesn’t have Catwoman as the worst comic movie ever needs to watch Catwoman again. Also, I personally don’t think animated features are comparable to live action, as the real thing is such an immersive experience... otherwise Mask of the Phantasm would be very, very high on my list. 22. Catwoman 21. Superman IV 20. Supergirl 19. Batman Forever 18. Superman III 17. Green Lantern 16. Batman & Robin 15. Suicide Squad 14.Justice League 13. Superman Returns 12. Dawn of Justice 11. The Dark Knight Rises 10. V for Vendetta 9. Watchmen 8. Constantine 7. Batman Returns 6. Man of Steel 5. Batman 4. Wonder Woman 3. Superman: The Movie 2. Batman Begins 1. The Dark Knight Where’s Superman II?
|
|