The Films of David Fincher

Gone Girl - 8/10
The Social Network - 8/10
Ths Game - 8/10
Panic Room - 8/10
The Killer - 7.5/10
Zodiac - 7.5/10
Se7en - 7.5/10
Fight Club - 7/10
Mank - 7/10
Alien³ - 7/10
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo - 7/10
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button - 6/10

I pretty much feel the same way about Fight Club. I wasn't obsessed (I am a generation older than the target audience) but I did admire it quite a bit - for a while. Eventually, the Fincher Sour Taste that I mentioned in my earlier reply started to creep in. It's funny how liking and admiration has turned to distaste over the years.

Gone Girl - 6
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo - 6
The Social Network - 3
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button - N/A
Zodiac - 9
Panic Room - 5
Fight Club - 9
The Game - 5
Se7en - 8
ALIEN³ - 4

To be fair, my view of The Social Network as a film is extremely biased for several reasons.

1.) I don't understand why this is a movie; more specifically, why it's a movie while Facebook is still relevant. Seems like a film that should come out in 20 years.
2.) I hate Facebook (never used it), I hate movies about assholes and Mark Zuckerberg is an asshole. At one point a character in the film tells him he isn't an asshole, he just tries to be. He absolutely is, in real life and in the film. I don't understand that line.
3.) I've never seen it start to finish (for the reasons previously mentioned), just bits and pieces on tv.

Fight Club is one of my favorite comedies of all time. Zodiac and Seven are phenomenal films. I think Fincher is an excellent director, so I actually gave him an extra point for each of the other films I haven't mentioned by name yet. They didn't pull me in due to subject matter (well Alien 3 was a train wreck of studio interference so he gets a pass there) but they're all superbly crafted as films go.

The Assembly Cut of "ALIEN 3" is Fantastic!

It is almost a Completely Different Movie.

I haven't seen enough to answer comprehensively, but Gone Girl, Zodiac and The Curious Case of Benjamin Button have been on my Watchlist for so long. Glad to see them scoring so highly on this poll.

1. Zodiac 9/10
2. Fight Club 9/10
3. The Game 8/10
4. Alien3 (assembley cut) 8/10
5. The Social Network 7.5
6. Se7en 7/10
7. Girl with the Dragon Tattoo 6.5
8. Gone Girl 6.5
9. Panic Room 4/10
10. Benjamin Button 3/10

8

Zodiac

7

Se7en
The Social Network
Fight Club
Gone Girl

5

Alien 3
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button

4

Panic Room

He's one of the most overrated directors, especially over the last 20 years or so. I have seen pretty much all of his movies besides Gone Girl (and maybe somewhat Alien 3(I think I have at least seen bits-and-pieces of this at some point in the past even though I don't have it rated on IMDb)).

None of his movies are worth re-watching for me at this point in time.

p.s. Fight Club (1999) is pretty much the gold standard of overrated if you ask me as it's the highest ranked movie in IMDb's Top 250 that I think is below average at best. for the record... I used to think it was a solid movie back around the early-to-mid 2000's and then I went quite a few years without re-watching it and then re-watched it on Apr 10th 2013 and prior to that viewing I had a feeling it was going to take a hit for me but I did not expect to dislike it as much as I did. it's basically below average/borderline failure for me at a 3.5-4/10.