|
Post by jammer81386 on Jan 13, 2019 6:51:24 GMT
For those who are not familiar, Grand Admiral Thrawn was a popular character from the old expanded universe. He was first introduced in the early 1990s by author Timothy Zahn in his trilogy of Heir to the Empire, Dark Force Rising, and The Last Command. Because of his popularity he was the first character from the old continuity to move over to the current canon with Zahn returning as author.
In short, the novel was very enjoyable. I actually liked it a bit better than Outbound Flight which was Thrawn's "origin story" in Legends continuity. Unlike most Star Wars media, this book is less of an action-adventure story and more of a political thriller. In fact, there really isn't an action scene until halfway through the book. But that in no way means that the book is boring, the political maneuvering and character interaction are very engaging. The two new character Eli Vanto and Arihnda Pryce do leave a notable impression. Zahn does a good job defining their character traits through their dialogue and actions. Vanto is intelligent but often out of his element and Pryce is always tetering the line between an anti-hero and villain. Both of their stories are intriguing.
However, the main attraction of the story is of course Thrawn. As expected he is the highlight of story. His logical reasoning and tactical sensibilities are as enjoyable as they have always been. Again Zahn does a good job in illustrating both making rather complex concepts easy to comprehend.
There are a few shortcoming. The biggest of which is that the final battle is rather anti-climatic. Without going into too much detail, Thrawn's strategy goes too much according to plan. A few unexpected occurrences would have forced Thrawn to adapt his plan and improvise, which would have been interesting to see. Also the antagonist of the story, called "nightswan", could have used a little more "screen time". His character is well defined, but him having a few more "shining moments" would have made him more a threat.
But that certainly shouldn't dissuade you from picking up the book if you are interested. I was an excellent novel and is well worth the read.
|
|
|
Post by Nalkarj on Jan 13, 2019 18:01:43 GMT
Funny question, perhaps, but how was the writing? I tried to read an “authorized” Indiana Jones fan-fiction novel once, and while the concept was decent the writing and characterization were some of the worst I’ve ever read.
But the Ackbars and Colden seem to like this character a lot, and he seems interesting (and somewhat close to the character I would have proposed for a sequel villain).
|
|
|
Post by jammer81386 on Jan 14, 2019 18:54:43 GMT
Funny question, perhaps, but how was the writing? I tried to read an “authorized” Indiana Jones fan-fiction novel once, and while the concept was decent the writing and characterization were some of the worst I’ve ever read. But the Ackbars and Colden seem to like this character a lot, and he seems interesting (and somewhat close to the character I would have proposed for a sequel villain). I personally thought the writing was very good. Timothy Zahn does have a talent for getting the dialogue and syntax perfectly. Whenever I read the dialogue in the old Thrawn trilogy, I would always hear the characters voices in my head. Granted this is not really applicable to the novel I reviewed as the only characters from the movies to appear in it for a significant amount of time are The Emperor and Moff Tarkin. In regards to the newer characters, I think you get a good sense of the personalities as pretty quick. For example, early in the novel Eli Vanto is shown to be intelligent by offering suggestions and ideas at times, but he also has a tendency to speak out of turn or when staying quiet would be a better option. Showing that he is smart but inexperienced. I rest of the writing i found easy to follow. I stated in my OP, the military operations that take place are describe in a concise and comprehensible way. So I was never confused about what was happening. Granted I am far from a literary critic, but I felt the novel was well written and your past experiences should not prevent you from at least giving this novel a shot.
|
|