Rate the Good Guys in Each of the 8 "STAR WARS" Movies!

TPM

QuiGon Jinn = 8/10 -- good example of prequel Jedi
ObiWan = 7/10 -- showed true nature of a Padawan
Padmé = 7/10 -- sold the dual identity
Anakin = 5/10 -- subpar child actor at times, spotty wunderkind
Shmi = 6/10 -- adequate
Jar Jar = 2/10 -- Nooooooo! (Vader scream)
Yoda = 10/10 -- best puppet performance, not best Yoda story
Mace Windu = 7/10 -- Jedi Counsel cool
Capt. Panaka = 6/10 -- shrinked into complaining but dependable when it counts
C3PO = 9/10 -- don't care Vader made him in TPM, captured true 3PO characterization
R2D2 = 5/10 -- 2nd least memorable performance
Vallorum = 7/10 -- great aristocratic characterization
KiAdi Mundi = 7/10 -- Jedi Counsel cool


AOTC

ObiWan = 9/10 -- nailed it!
Anakin = 7/10 -- whiny was not the problem at this point, romance could've been better
Padmé = 5/10 -- adequate sometimes, stiff at others
Yoda = 7/10 -- good, but pinball fighting style is divisive
Mace Windu = 10/10 -- at his best on Geonosis
Bail Organa = 4/10 -- not much of a cameo
C3PO = 8/10 -- shined on Geonosis, classic 3PO humor
R2D2 = 7/10 -- stepping more into his personality
Ki-Adi Mundi = 5/10 -- seemed more background in AOTC
Jar Jar = 1/10 -- cameos that weren't even necessary
Shmi = 8/10 -- great performance in death scene


ROTS

ObiWan = 10/10 -- arguably the best ObiWan
Anakin = 8/10 -- had to take a point off because he should've been less whiny at this point
Padmé = 6/10 -- okay
Yoda = 9/10 -- "Powerful Jedi was he! Powerful Jedi!"
Windu = 9/10 -- great lines and... he "didn't go out like a punk"!
Bail Organa = 8/10 -- nailed the character, filled out the role
C3PO = 4/10 -- background fluff
R2D2 = 7/10 -- great in battle over Coruscant, forgettable after that
Chewbacca = 7/10 -- briefly brings the pain, and w/o being a doormat
Ki-Adi Mundi = 8/10 -- a noble Jedi who went out like a hero


ANH

Luke Skywalker = 10/10
Han Solo = 10/10
Princess Leia = 10/10
Ben Kenobi = 10/10 -- A flawless performance from a legendary actor
Chewbacca = 9/10
C3PO = 10/10
R2D2 = 10/10
Biggs Darklighter = 8/10 -- great character, should've left in his deleted scene
Wedge = 9/10 -- ace pilot, cool character


TESB

Luke = 10/10
Han = 10/10
Leia = 10/10
Lando = 10/10
Chewbacca = 10/10
C3PO = 10/10
R2D2 = 10/10
General Rieekan = 6/10 -- noble background character
Yoda = 10/10
Ben/ObiWan = 9/10 -- scaled to background but still great
Wedge = 7/10 -- not as significant in TESB
Zev = 5/10 -- barely remember him
Dak = 6/10 -- one exuberant line then he dies
Lobot = 7/10 -- mesmerizing, cool background character


ROTJ

Luke = 10/10
Han = 10/10
Leia = 10/10
Lando = 10/10
Chewbacca = 10/10
C3PO = 10/10
R2D2 = 9/10
Yoda = 10/10
ObiWan = 8/10 -- wonderful cameo
Wicket = 9/10 -- great performance despite a species that might've been a little too cute and fluff
Wedge = 10/10 -- his best movie
Mon Mothma = 10/10
Admiral Ackbar = 10/10 -- legendary!
Nien Nunb = 9/10


TFA

Rey = 6.5/10 -- lively new character and first star female Force user in episodic movies, unfortunately her characterization is that of a Disney princess and uses the Force even more like one
Finn = 5/10 -- his backstory and his characterization couldn't be farther apart
Poe = 7/10 -- a respectable entry as the lead X-wing pilot, but occasionally came off a little MarySue-ish
Han Solo = 9/10 -- the best character performance and the only one who always felt like real "OT style", not just pretending
General Leia = 8/10 -- not equal to her OT character or performance but very good
Luke Skywalker = 6/10 -- a non-dialogue cameo in the last few minutes; if this was anyone else (and not for a facial expression that carried a lot of emotion), I would've graded it a 3/10
Chewbacca = 7/10 -- being classic Chewbacca except when he was pining over Rey and being her doormat
C3PO = 2/10 -- "you want to know about my red arm?" and "I doubt R2 would have the map" (despite the fact he is owned by Luke and was in his possession before his power down); a couple of dreadful cameos that made him sound stupid (even for a droid)
R2D2 = 4/10 -- was just there for a contrived McGuffin; but at least he didn't make himself look stupid, just the writers
BB8 = 8/10 -- he had all the personality of R2 but came up short on functionality save carrying the map piece
Maz = 6/10 -- sounds captivatingly wise like Yoda but needs to back it up more in her actions
Lor San Tekka = 9/10 -- intriguing character that was well acted, just gone too soon
Admiral Ackbar = 10/10 -- nailed it but could've used a few more lines
Nien Nunb = 8/10 -- a little more screen time would've been nice
Snap Wexley = 3/10 -- who??
Admiral Statura = 7/10 -- did his part as a background general


Rogue One

Jyn Erso = 8/10
Cassian Andor = 7/10
Chirrut Imwe = 9/10
Baze Malbus = 8/10
Bohdi Rook = 7/10
K-2SO = 8/10 -- his lack of facial expression sometimes hurt his ability to be funny; Lucas compensated for that same problem with C3PO by hiring a mime to deliver exaggerated body language; K-2SO lacked in that also somewhat; but the talented voice of Alan Tudyk help make up for it
Galen Erso = 8/10
Saw Guerrera = 7/10
Mon Mothma = 10/10
Bail Organa = 9/10
General Draven = 6/10
Lyra Erso = 6/10
Admiral Raddus = 9/10 -- he did the Mon Calamari proud
Blue Leader = 9/10 -- one of the coolest generals and pilots, too bad he only got to be single movie character
Red Leader = 7/10
Gold Leader = 6/10