Zelda: Wind Waker or Twilight Princess?

I enjoyed The Wind Waker far more than Twilight Princess.

I feel they spent more time coming up with the great graphics than coming up with fun, inventive gameplay.

I'm glad I'm not the only one who did not enjoy Skyward Sword. It was a tedious chore.

It lacked any of the enjoyment or wonder Zelda's greatest games possessed.

Indeed. So many bosses were difficult not because they were a true challenge, but because the motion controls wouldn't register precise movements.

I enjoy both games, but I'd choose Wind Waker as being the better game.

Wind Waker might throw you off with its cartoonish look at first, but the feature of sailing from island to island and exploring gives it a unique element to stand out from the other Zelda games. Despite having only four main dungeons, it still feels like an involving game that offers a lot to do throughout.

Twilight Princess is a fun game and I liked the whole trippy alternate realm where Link turns into the wolf, but I just felt like a lot of the game (dungeons, locations, weapons) is recycled from Ocarina of Time. Good one, yet lacking a little in innovation.