Post by Toasted Cheese on Dec 7, 2017 23:54:30 GMT
While Freddy might look scary in parts, the film just isn't that scary overall, but it is a bit creepy. That of course is highlighted with Coach Schneider's character, but creepy in a different way. It does have oodles of that 80's horror movie atmosphere though and it was even an original attempt at blending horror, slasher and teen angst sexuality\confusion drama into the mix. What does work in it, works quite well. The thing is, it wasn't exactly better than the sum of it's part.
If they had a better actress for a leading lady, a reshot sequence when Lisa takes Jesse to the steelworks for the first time, that doesn't make her look so pathetic at the cute rat in the metal cabinet, a climax that contained a few more nightmarish horror elements—Lisa seeing the dogs with human faces, and the illusionary bite injury on her leg with insets crawling on it weren't enough—and perhaps a bit more of a bold attempt to bring to the fore Jesse's sexuality, it might have made more of an impact on audiences. If Jesse had admitted to Grady that he was gay and Grady gives him an adverse reaction before he turns into Freddy and then kills him, that would have been so much more potent. I can't see someone like Grady being accepting and cool with it, he was too much of a jerk. Or lets be even more brazen, and have Grady come out to Jesse too and they sleep together and then Jesse wakes up and turns into Freddy and kills him. It would have made Freddy even more madder, because he wanted Jesse to be in conflict with himself and not succumb. That is how he feeds of fear and anxiety. That would have been way too shocking for the simpleminded herd at the time, perhaps even today.
One flatmate of mine years ago, commented he didn't like it because it was kind of gay. Well yeah! That was the point.
Creepy is definitely the word. Honestly, I only found Freddy scary in "New Nightmare." Apart from that, he's always been creepier than he's been scary.
I identified with Grady a bit. One of my best friends in high school (big jock, incredible baseball player) started to learn he was gay. I (and the rest of our circle of friends) am hetero. We were also big stoners, and as stoners are wont to do, we discussed stuff. One night, my friend came out to us. We were all cool with it...it was nice to hear him say it actually. Dude was bottled up for a good two years (probably more) and was clearly stressed out about it. We were worried about him (one of my friends thought it was steroids). While I've been hetero my entire life, his struggle became very real to me. He came from a conservative family and was likely to catch a belt if he even whispered about his feelings. This movie holds a special place in my heart because it was gay! Though I'm not gay myself, it is way ahead of its time regarding the internal struggle a burgeoning gay man may deal with. Hell, it was weird dealing with feelings growing up hetero! The stigmas and stereotypes are dealt with very well in this movie (I thought).
My bud, btw, is happily married to his husband in Seattle. Two dudes who love each other (with tons of disposable income). Last I heard, they were in vacationing in Stressa, Italy in the hotel Hemingway did a lot of writing. His struggle was real and he made it out on top. "Part 2" helped me understand how difficult his journey may have been. Our circle of friends never razzed or joked about it...we saw how hard it was for him in other parts of life.
This movie is definitely a good watch for a hetero dude with a friend who's realizing he's homo. The allegory is great, the horror is on point (sometimes). It was way ahead of its time. A black sheep for the NOES saga, but an underrated film IMHO.
You seem very nice, can't you claim to be just a little bi, instead of a boring het.

As for this installment, yes, it was on point for some of the time and that is a valid and decent positive criticism. However, the gay allegory would get lost on many due to it's wishy washy handling in parts. A nice try at best.

