Post by moviemouth on Feb 11, 2018 2:52:38 GMT
-Jerry Maguire (1996) - 9/10 (within my Top 26 movies and is my #1 Tom Cruise movie (no one beats Tom Cruise filmography in general as he's got 13 movies I score a 7/10 or higher). April 19th 2016 is my most recent re-watch of this.)
-Silver Linings Playbook (2012) - 5/10 (Thumbs Down (it's watchable, but forgettable))
Marv
Im inclined to say yes. Having said that i havent felt the desire to rewatch SLP but i have rewatch Jerry Maguire several times over the years.
clearly Jerry Maguire is superior for you given the re-watch factor as you having no desire to re-watch SLP speaks volumes about it. hence, it's not even close to Jerry Maguire but yet you said 'Yes'.
because as I always say a movies true worth is whether it's a movie you want to re-watch from time-to-time as the years pass or not this separates the truly good movies from the 'just another movie' type of movie.
p.s. in the long run... SLP will be forgotten, as I think it mostly is already, where as Jerry Maguire will not be forgotten especially given Tom Cruise is tied to it and he's someone who will be remembered a long time from now. I think Jerry Maguire is also THE movie people will remember Cuba Gooding Jr for also which further amps up the movie.
Not everyone judges a movie's quality on re-watch value.
I feel that explaining the reasons to you will be pointless because you simply don't see movies they same way I do.