Is the “WW got good reviews because feminism” argument dead?

Is the “WW got good reviews because feminism” argument dead? Mar 18, 2018 19:24:37 GMT

Quote

Post by formersamhmd on Mar 18, 2018 19:24:37 GMT

Mar 18, 2018 16:43:54 GMT thisguy4000 said:

Mar 18, 2018 16:37:08 GMT formersamhmd said:

It was forever, as in he should never be played by another actor no matter what or if the series was rebooted and he shouldn't be used in any other media ever either. Total retirement, total fanaticism.

Williams already got an Oscar in 1998. The academy wouldn't think "Oh, now we can't give him one."

Given that the Joker was used in other media shortly after TDK (including the well received animated movie titled Under the Red Hood), your argument has little weight to it.

You claimed that Heath Ledger only got an Oscar nod because he was an “Oscar darling”. I was simply pointing out that if we went by your logic, Robin Williams should’ve been nominated for an Oscar for his final performance as well, given how much the Academy loved him.

I'm not saying they succeeded, just that they thought they could succeed. Which speaks volumes.

They wanted to give him one since Brokeback and once he died they knew they'd never be able to give him one for a "proper" movie. Williams already had an Oscar so there was less incentive.