The portrayal of an ex-Stormtrooper: The Finn poll

The portrayal of an ex-Stormtrooper: The Finn poll Apr 8, 2018 20:42:14 GMT

Quote

Post by formersamhmd on Apr 8, 2018 20:42:14 GMT

Apr 8, 2018 20:36:31 GMT @captaintarpals said:

Apr 8, 2018 19:49:25 GMT formersamhmd said:

Trust me, having the ST open up like 100 years after the OT with the OT characters long gone, film would've bombed.

It deserves to bomb anyway. If'n these new ST characters can't stand on their own, it deserves to bomb. Yousa just admitted dat da trilogy is dependent on thems.

I'm saying the OT fans would've ripped the movie apart for not having the OT characters in it. See what I mean about the no-win scenario?

Meesa doesn't have to prove anything cuz yousa hasn't proven dat OT fans wouldn't accept OT and ST characters sharing da spotlight.

Look at how they've reacted thus far.

Wrong-o! Jar Jar was a bad character and Lucas got no protection bout it.

He also wasn't a lead.

Wrong-o with QuiGon. Hims needed ObiWan's help against Darth Maul.

Seeing how he died, help didn't matter in the end. I'm sure you'd be happy if Rey died in her first movie.

Weesa also knows QuiGon needed a lifetime of training to gets to be a Jedi master

And if Rey had been some star pupil Jedi Student of Lukes, she'd just get derided for being a star student.

Wrong-o bout ObiWan. Hims needed to be mentored by QuiGon in TPM. In AOTC hims needed saving twice. In ROTS hims was saved by Anakin.

And if this happened to Rey, she'd just get ripped into and called a useless person who needed too much saving.

Yousa contradicting self again. Yousen said in other posts dat PT was hated. How can PT be hated and protected by fanbase at da same time?!?

Because they hate the ST so much they're willing to let go of their anger at the PT.