Post by charzhino on Aug 3, 2018 17:01:53 GMT
That would be fine and make sense however she grows up to become a physicist working for Dr Brand at NASA. She is in a perfect situation to understand all about the Lazarus mission and why her dad had to leave and wasnt sure when he was coming back (since she understood relativity by then).
If she became an uneducated farmer like her brother, it would make sense why she'd still hate Cooper because she wont have been briefed on the mission.
The Miller planet one is a flaw from a purely pragmatic sense which I think is very much intentional. The movie spends a great deal of time showing the inherent conflict between scientific research and decisions based on emotion. The entire movie is about that imo until the two can merge to create a solution.
Even if the planet had extreme time dilation, it was closest, it had a signal, and if they got in and out, based on Plan A, it could still be a planet that could be settled...Although unlikely to ever leave.
Ye I can excuse the Miller planet. I guess its from a scientific point of view why Id have a problem with it. They should have known prior before they landed that the planet had giant tidal waves,but that does destroy the surprise and shock element.