Post by Aj_June on Aug 7, 2018 6:34:35 GMT
What you mean to tell is that it is difficult for you to find good non-English movies. It seems to me that you are writing your opinion as a fact when you say that there are not many Non-English movies that stand out.
If non-English movies really do not stand out then how come they so often win Palme d'Or at Cannes, Golden Bear at Berlin and Golden Lion at Venice film festival.
Almost all the world recognises best directors having come from Germany, Italy, Sweden, Japan, Russia and many other countries. While USA (and other English nations) has its share of greatness in producing great movies and great directors such as Kubrik, they are not so far ahead that non-English movies don't stand out. Hell, even the best directors of USA continuously sing praises of great masters from all over the world.
If non-English movies really do not stand out then how come they so often win Palme d'Or at Cannes, Golden Bear at Berlin and Golden Lion at Venice film festival.
Almost all the world recognises best directors having come from Germany, Italy, Sweden, Japan, Russia and many other countries. While USA (and other English nations) has its share of greatness in producing great movies and great directors such as Kubrik, they are not so far ahead that non-English movies don't stand out. Hell, even the best directors of USA continuously sing praises of great masters from all over the world.
but yeah, directors can be good from other places but in the end your movie needs to be engaging/interesting/entertaining in some way or another and in this regard there are not many non-English language movies that stand out in my mind as even if the director has some talent, the whole movie has to click for it to work overall. I doubt I am the only person who feels that way as I would have to assume there are many people like myself in that while you can still find a quality non-English spoken movie from time-to-time they tend to be few, if not very few, especially in comparison to English language movies.
so if I looked strictly at where directors come from regardless if the movie is English language or not, I suspect there would be more quality directors in this regard that are not from English speaking countries. but in terms of movies where the spoken language is not English, that's where there is a very limited amount that stand out for me. there is only 187 movies out of the 2,200+ total movies I have seen that 'stand out' for me personally and out of those I can't imagine there is more than 20 tops (I think it's about 10 or less if I recall correctly) that are non-English spoken language. sure, there are probably some more gems of the non-English language type out there but I suspect it won't be easy to find them. hell, just straight up... it's getting difficult to find movies from the past (as movies in the future (say 2018+) still turn up here and there) that I have not already seen that are of any real worth for me.
also, those critics tend to be disconnected with many common people in general. so I don't put too much stock in critics as they all seem to kiss up to movies mainly because they break new ground or were ahead of their time etc more than them just being a great movie straight up (especially when they list Top 100 movies of all-time etc types of lists) that they like re-watching from time-to-time as, to me, the truly good movies are ones you want to re-watch here and there as the years pass. those that fail that basic test are ultimately forgettable and I would have to assume this is the mindset of many people out there as that's basically the point in watching movies is to find ones I want to re-watch from time-to-time. sort of like a good song.
p.s. basically I am not a person who's too easily pleased with movies in general as only about 8.5% of all movies I have seen 'stand out' from the pack. even being a bit generous that figure does not go much over 10%. so basically about 1 out of every 10 movies I see 'stand out' from the pack.
1) The non-English movies are not just praised by critics. They are praised by people alike.
2) Just because you find it difficult to find non-English movies doesn't mean they don't exist. A neutral person such as I who hasn't got preconceived ideas does not find it difficult to find non-English movies.
3) You are more than welcome to hold your opinion but they will just remain opinions. You posted your first post in a manner as if it is a fact that there are very few non-English movies that stand out. That's just your opinion.
4) There may be other people too who are not easily pleased by movies they see. I have rated 26 movies as 10/10 on IMDB. I think 21 of them are non-English. But I do not believe based on my opinion that English movies don't stand out. I recognise different people have differing views and it is just a subjective thing.


