Black Panther being pushed for Best Film nomination

Black Panther being pushed for Best Film nomination Sept 7, 2018 7:46:35 GMT

Quote

Post by summers8 on Sept 7, 2018 7:46:35 GMT

Sept 6, 2018 22:08:43 GMT bud47 said:

Sept 6, 2018 21:23:55 GMT amyghost said:

Yes, because that award, even debased as it is today, will confer on the film an 'artistic' legitimacy that mere popularity won't.

Which I don't feel it deserves, but there are plenty who'd disagree with me.

They don't make these films for Oscars. That's just not their aim and never has been. They don't need them. Their films are critical and box office hits. An Oscar (win or nomination) would just be an extra cherry on top.

You still don't get it. it is about what is deserving. mcu is not deserving their movies are poorly made, poorly written, generic , have no directorial input and have destroyed the credibility of comic books.

you mentioned critical hit but it is down to the content. You can't compare why movies like logan and tdk or even DOFP and Batman Begins are critical hit to why mcu movies are critical hits. also remember mcu critical hits have proven not to be credible. it is clear critics give their movies a pass...we are still waiting for Black panther to get the same harsh criticism for their bad cgi like Xmen origins and Justice league got. how come critics did not say anything?

Also critical hit because their movies are fun? try critical hits because your movie is a compelling drama like Logan, DOFP and TDK and is taken seriously. These are the comic films that will be more Oscar friendly based on merit. reason Disney wants to buy the awards and can't earn it. look at these two videos and tell me which is more Oscar looking

this from avengers 1

or this from xmen 1

based on the Oscar's history, it is laughable to think avengers 1 will get an Oscar nomination over X-Men 1.

lol..critical hits...mcu movies are transformers with faux good reviews..