Subtitles or dubbing over?

my fellow americans, what do you prefer to watch at home if u have the choice of either

1. watching a foreing show dubbed over into english
or
2. watching a foreign show in its native language with english subtitles(


let say both options have a good quality of the craft behind it (the subtitles or voices) and its a comedy genre.

and by dubbing over i dont mean speaking over/voiceover but actual actors speaking for the foreign actors.