Justice League Snyder's Scenes vs Wheedon

Justice League Snyder's Scenes vs Wheedon Nov 22, 2018 15:57:40 GMT DSDSquared likes this

Quote

Post by sostie on Nov 22, 2018 15:57:40 GMT

Nov 22, 2018 15:23:14 GMT @thegodfather said:

Nov 22, 2018 14:57:26 GMT sostie said:

The Russian family was a Whedon thing, but it totalled nothing near 15 minutes, and the CGI lip I wished was 10 minutes as it was the highlight of the film.

Whether the other stuff was going to eventually be in the film or not who knows. A likewise if it would have made it better. If Snyder had directed some it still didn't bode well if we got his "vision" because all of it was crap. It still would have Steppenwolf and Cyborg in it so no improvement there.

Okay, let's say you're right (I don't believe you) but I'll go along with it for arguments sake.

80% of a 1 hour 55 minute film is like 100 minutes (or approx 1 hour 40 minutes).

That doesn't mean he didn't shoot 3.5 hours or 210 minutes of footage and they only used 100 minutes of Snyder's film and Wheedon added 15 or 20 minutes of his cheaply made nonsesne to tie it together.

That's still not the same as saying it's 85% Snyder's cut or vision.

Right or wrong it doesn't matter. My opinion is no matter what percentage each director made, it was ALL crap. And I can't imagine anything added would have made it any better. BvS wasn't exactly a great film...throwing in a terrible villain, and adding a sad crap robot, a Mutant Turtle in human form and an irritating speedster to the team I doubt would have made a better film, whether 10% or 100% Snyder