Post by Deleted on Dec 31, 2018 8:48:22 GMT
This year it seems to be really close. Baker set a record for TD passes by a rookie in 27 breaking Peyton Manning's record of 26 and he didn't even play the entire year.
Then you have Barkley who has just been one of the best backs in the league since the moment he stepped foot on the field. He reached over 2000 yards from scrimmage as a rookie becoming the 3rd to ever do that (Eric Dickerson and Edgeriin James). He also broke Reggie Bush's rookie record of 88 catches.
I personally would vote for Barkley because of his stats coming with a team that has a horrid offensive line and yet he was still able to do what it is that he has done. However what Baker has done can't be ignored. He has brought the Browns back from the cellar of the NFL.
Then you have Barkley who has just been one of the best backs in the league since the moment he stepped foot on the field. He reached over 2000 yards from scrimmage as a rookie becoming the 3rd to ever do that (Eric Dickerson and Edgeriin James). He also broke Reggie Bush's rookie record of 88 catches.
I personally would vote for Barkley because of his stats coming with a team that has a horrid offensive line and yet he was still able to do what it is that he has done. However what Baker has done can't be ignored. He has brought the Browns back from the cellar of the NFL.