Post by BATouttaheck on Apr 10, 2017 1:53:04 GMT
howardschumann
"So which version of "A Christmas Carol" was your favorite?"
I don't really do favorites. I liked several of them for assorted reasons and actively disliked only one.
Sim used to be my "go-to" Scrooge and he was tied with Scott after 1984.
I had never seen the Hicks one until the quest and really liked it. I found some of my notes --- seems it is now a 3 way tie !
I liked Rathbone's Scrooge but did not like Fredric March at all ! The face making at the end was just creepy.
Scrooged was not really "A Christmas Carol" and in any case I hated it with a passion even though Bill Murray is an actor I normally like.
It was very interesting to see the silent versions even though they were either short intentionally or just rescued clips.
Do you have a favored version ?
"So which version of "A Christmas Carol" was your favorite?"
I don't really do favorites. I liked several of them for assorted reasons and actively disliked only one.
Sim used to be my "go-to" Scrooge and he was tied with Scott after 1984.
I had never seen the Hicks one until the quest and really liked it. I found some of my notes --- seems it is now a 3 way tie !
I liked Rathbone's Scrooge but did not like Fredric March at all ! The face making at the end was just creepy.
Scrooged was not really "A Christmas Carol" and in any case I hated it with a passion even though Bill Murray is an actor I normally like.
It was very interesting to see the silent versions even though they were either short intentionally or just rescued clips.
Do you have a favored version ?