Post by glozone on Jan 16, 2019 16:28:51 GMT
With us now seeing both Brady Blacks onscreen as different characters, Alex North-style, I'm interested to know in who your favorites of all these recasted characters are? I'm not including some (like Lexie and Kayla) where there may have been other versions, but they were short-lived and probably no one remembers them. I'm also not including child versions of characters. There's also ones I suspect a lot of us can't do, like Laura, where I assume most of us have just seen Jaime-Lynn Bauer and missed Susan Flannery's more crucial one.
I've ranked mine from favorite to least favorite. Do the same!
Just to get these three out of the way....
Bo Brady
1. Peter Reckell
2. Robert Kelker-Kelly
Jennifer Horton
1. Melissa Reeves
2. Stephanie Cameron
Jack Deveraux
1. Matthew Ashford
2. Mark Valley
3. Steve Wilder
(I'm assuming no one even remembers Joseph Adams and James Acheson)
I hazard a guess this is everyone's order for them.
Brady Black
1. Eric Martsolf
2. Kyle Lowder
Philip Kiriakis
1. Jay Johnson
2. John-Paul Lavoisier
3. Kyle Brandt
Belle Black
1. Martha Madison
2. Kirsten Storms
Shawn D. Brady
1. Jason Cook
2. Brandon Beemer
Abigail Deveraux
1. Kate Mansi
2. Ashley Benson
3. Marci Miller
(Special shot-out to Megan Corletto though, who was a great little kid Abby)
Chad DiMera
1. Casey Jon Diedrick
2. Billy Flynn
(I'm sure this is unpopular, but Billy's Chad just seems like an entirely different person who functions as like... E.J.-Lite. I liked Chad better as this dumb kid who randomly turned out to be a DiMera. Not all, like, wearing vests and running DiMera Enterprises because he's the last DiMera standing)
Austin Reed
1. Austin Peck
2. Patrick Muldoon
(They both suck. But at least Austin Peck is good at what I feel Austin has become... a vapid handsome object to be fought over. Patrick Muldoon's tries too hard to be interesting, which Muldoon can't pull off. And he's aged badly.)
Billie Reed
1. Julie Pinson
2. Lisa Rinna
3. Krista Allen
(Julie's is the only one I like at all)
Roman Brady
1. Josh Taylor
2. Wayne Northrop
(Wayne's will always be the most important one, but Josh has been in the role so long, that even if his Roman is kind of lame and pointless, he's Roman to me.)
Will Horton
1. Chandler Massey
2. Christopher Gerse (he played him into his teens, so I count him)
3. Guy Wilson
4. Dylan Patton
Mike Horton
1. Roark Critchlow
2. Michael T. Weiss (His Mike was funny from what I saw, so I'd probably like him a lot, but Roark is Mike to me and I was a big Mike/Carrie fan)
3. Wesley Eure (Sorry, never seen a second of ya!)
Any others I should be including?
I've ranked mine from favorite to least favorite. Do the same!
Just to get these three out of the way....
Bo Brady
1. Peter Reckell
2. Robert Kelker-Kelly
Jennifer Horton
1. Melissa Reeves
2. Stephanie Cameron
Jack Deveraux
1. Matthew Ashford
2. Mark Valley
3. Steve Wilder
(I'm assuming no one even remembers Joseph Adams and James Acheson)
I hazard a guess this is everyone's order for them.
Brady Black
1. Eric Martsolf
2. Kyle Lowder
Philip Kiriakis
1. Jay Johnson
2. John-Paul Lavoisier
3. Kyle Brandt
Belle Black
1. Martha Madison
2. Kirsten Storms
Shawn D. Brady
1. Jason Cook
2. Brandon Beemer
Abigail Deveraux
1. Kate Mansi
2. Ashley Benson
3. Marci Miller
(Special shot-out to Megan Corletto though, who was a great little kid Abby)
Chad DiMera
1. Casey Jon Diedrick
2. Billy Flynn
(I'm sure this is unpopular, but Billy's Chad just seems like an entirely different person who functions as like... E.J.-Lite. I liked Chad better as this dumb kid who randomly turned out to be a DiMera. Not all, like, wearing vests and running DiMera Enterprises because he's the last DiMera standing)
Austin Reed
1. Austin Peck
2. Patrick Muldoon
(They both suck. But at least Austin Peck is good at what I feel Austin has become... a vapid handsome object to be fought over. Patrick Muldoon's tries too hard to be interesting, which Muldoon can't pull off. And he's aged badly.)
Billie Reed
1. Julie Pinson
2. Lisa Rinna
3. Krista Allen
(Julie's is the only one I like at all)
Roman Brady
1. Josh Taylor
2. Wayne Northrop
(Wayne's will always be the most important one, but Josh has been in the role so long, that even if his Roman is kind of lame and pointless, he's Roman to me.)
Will Horton
1. Chandler Massey
2. Christopher Gerse (he played him into his teens, so I count him)
3. Guy Wilson
4. Dylan Patton
Mike Horton
1. Roark Critchlow
2. Michael T. Weiss (His Mike was funny from what I saw, so I'd probably like him a lot, but Roark is Mike to me and I was a big Mike/Carrie fan)
3. Wesley Eure (Sorry, never seen a second of ya!)
Any others I should be including?
