Post by DC-Fan on May 23, 2017 8:27:21 GMT
No, Tony didn't have Government Authority to kidnap Peter. Peter is a private citizen and isn't in the military so the government doesn't have the authority to draft him into service. Moreover, Peter is a minor so he couldn't be drafted anyway. And the government has no authority to allow anyone to kidnap a minor and transport the minor out of the country without the consent of the minor's parents or legal guardian.
Also, what Peter wants is irrelevant. Peter is a minor so under the law, Peter isn't allowed to leave the country without the consent of his parents or legal guardian. Since Peter is a minor, transporting him out of the country under false pretenses and lying to Aunt May is considered kidnapping of a child, regardless of whether or not the child went voluntarily. Since Peter is a child, he's not legally able to give consent so what Peter wants is irrelevant.
General Ross has no parental or legal guardian rights over Peter so General Ross can't give Stark any permission for Peter to be on the team. Since Peter is a minor, the only person who can give permission for Peter to be on the team is his legal guardian, Aunt May. But Stark lied to Aunt May and took Peter out of the country under false pretenses. That's kidnapping of a child.
And you dumb MCU fans obviously don't know how to read. Like I already said, what Peter wants is irrelevant. Peter is a minor so under the law, Peter isn't allowed to leave the country without the consent of his parents or legal guardian. Since Peter is a minor, transporting him out of the country under false pretenses and lying to Aunt May is considered kidnapping of a child, regardless of whether or not the child went voluntarily. Since Peter is a child, he's not legally able to give consent so what Peter wants is irrelevant.