Post by ArArArchStanton on Feb 25, 2017 2:14:45 GMT
Feb 24, 2017 6:00:43 GMT @weirdraptor said:
It isn't too crammed if you just stick with what Tolkien wrote for it and don't bother with any of the Appendex materials. Bilbo finds The Ring, the core component that makes The Lord of the Rings functionable as a story.I think it is whether you stick to what Tolkien wrote or not. There are so many different action sets that you can spend a little extra time with each and have tons available for two films. There is simply no reason do it all in one.
Just because it's in one book doesn't mean there is some obligation to put it in one film, or that it's better off that way.
Sorry, I completely disagree and have put a lot of thought into this, so you won't be convincing me.