Post by Skaathar on May 31, 2017 16:47:27 GMT
As for Thor's personality change, yes, it's a problem if it was too short. It's called proper character development. That aspect of his character wasn't properly developed, and so his personality change didn't feel natural. It felt contrived and weak. And that is a flaw. Take note that a flaw is not a plothole nor is it some glaring mistake. A flaw can simply be a weakness. Flawed implies not perfect. And in this case, having such a huge personality change over 2 days when you're around 1000 years old IS a flaw. And him falling for Jane just because she was a "hot nice chick" makes Thor look really shallow.
You saw the trading cards right? It was based on that. That's one of the reasons why Coulson made such a big deal out of them. That was his vision of Cap. I didn't even know this was in debate. I thought it was obvious. And that being the case, it's a benefit to the film by adding some depth to why it is the way it is. You make it sound like they just created a cheesy suit because they fucked up, which isn't the case.
I found Thor's arc to be proper character development. It felt natural to me. As I said, I'm not sure writing the narrative so that it took longer would make the story any better. And falling for a hot nice chick doesn't make you shallow. Try being anywhere alone for a couple of days, especially some place you don't want to be, when you just lost something major, and see how you feel when some really nice cute girl says hi to you and tell me it doesn't make your day.
Did you have another example of something bad? These don't pose any problem as far as I can tell.
Pretty sure I can survive alone for 2 days in a crappy environment without falling in love with the first hot chick I meet. Will I be happy for her company? Absolutely. Doesn't mean I'll develop such a strong connection to her that I will throw away my princely duties just to be with her. That makes Thor look immature and completely negates the supposed personality development he had.
As for Thor's personality change... like I said, it doesn't matter what criticism I make, you'll turn a blind eye to it and cover your ears. If you think it only takes 2 days to completely change habits and traits you've developed for hundreds of years well... then there's no reasoning with you.
I just listed 2 completely legitimate problems of MCU movies. Problems that have been pointed out time and again by multiple people. Just because YOU don't think they're problems doesn't mean that they aren't. I bet if I say that Malekith is a ridiculously weakly developed villain that you'd go and defend that as well.