moonlight91
New Member
Salutations
@moonlight91
Posts: 24
|
Post by moonlight91 on Mar 3, 2017 5:33:17 GMT
I have watched Gone With The Wind since I was nine where when I tell people its my favorite movie, they are shocked as though I am not suppose to like it or something. I remember one time being 12 reading the book where the Principal at my school saw me reading it and just couldn't imagine it until I told her my admiration for Scarlett.
I don't see this movie as racist, yes it is setting in the Old South; yet this movie can be told in any setting as it is the story of how to survive when one is on the losing side. Scarlet is probably one of the most complex characters where calling her a manipulative bitch is a shallow interpretation. Mammy is a great character, I love how the film expanded her character from the book (in which she took Archie and Will's roles in the second half) and we got some wonderful moments of her being the logic in the film. The only character I never could stand was Prissy, I want to throw a book at her if it got her to stop screeching.
|
|
|
|
Post by jeffersoncody on Mar 3, 2017 7:40:25 GMT
I'm sure slimy white nationalists like Jeff Sessions and David Duke don't see themselves as racists moonlight. But they are racists.
I have seen GONE WITH THE WIND many times - and it's certainly a sweeping, well made film with an engaging story - but each time I watch it, it gets harder for me to remove the bad taste from my mouth. Please give me even one example of where it condemns the vile, inhumane practise of slavery.
I understand that the racist white southerners in the story (who include Scarlett, Melanie, Ashley and, too only a slightly lesser extent, Rhett) are too self involved, priviliged and greedy to see themselves as the racists they are, but the filmmakers should have made the film in such a way that it showed just how horrific, cruel and dehumanising slavery really was.
|
|
|
|
Post by snsurone on Mar 3, 2017 18:51:53 GMT
And let's not forget the snake oil salesman in the White House who adamantly denies being racist and anti-Semitic!
But...let's not get into 21st century politics here.
As I said in an earlier post, the movie is far less racist than the novel. In fact, the book takes pains to point out that black people were better off as slaves than as freedmen. It's difficult to believe that anyone could feel that way considering the physical proof of the treatment slaves received, but it's apparent that Margaret Mitchell and those in her orbit believed it. Sometimes I wonder: if she had lived during the Civil Rights Movement of the 1960's, would her opinion have changed? I don't think so.
|
|