kratos
Sophomore
@kratos
Posts: 141
Likes: 107
|
Post by kratos on Aug 14, 2018 23:45:12 GMT
I'd though I'd try this little game. So I'm gonna compare a MCU movie to a non MCU movie that came out the same year (when possible).
Pick which movie you prefer and then tally up how many MCU movies you voted for and how many non MCU movies you voted for and see which gets more votes.
Iron Man vs The Dark Knight
The Incredible Hulk vs Punisher Warzone
Iron Man 2 vs X-men Origins Wolverine
Thor vs X-men First Class
Captain America vs Green Lantern
The Avengers vs The Dark Knight Rises
Iron Man 3 vs The Wolverine
Thor Dark World vs Man of Steel
Captain America Winter Soldier vs The Amazing Spider-man 2
Guardians of the Galaxy vs X-men Days of Future Past
Avengers Age of Ultron vs Fantastic Four
Ant-man vs Deadpool
Captain America Civil War vs Batman vs Superman
Doctor Strange vs X-men Apocalypse
Guardians of the Galaxy 2 vs Justice League
Spider-man Homecoming vs Logan
Thor Ragnarok vs Wonder Woman
Black Panther vs Deadpool 2
Avengers Infinity War vs Incredibles 2
Ant-man and the Wasp vs Teen Titans Go to the Movies
|
|
|
|
Post by politicidal on Aug 15, 2018 0:03:38 GMT
13 total in favor of MCU (Two comparisons, I hadn't seen the other film).
4 for non-MCU.
3 were about even.
|
|
|
|
Post by scabab on Aug 15, 2018 1:10:02 GMT
Iron Man vs The Dark Knight
The Incredible Hulk vs Punisher Warzone
Iron Man 2 vs X-men Origins Wolverine
Thor vs X-men First Class
Captain America vs Green Lantern
The Avengers vs The Dark Knight Rises
Iron Man 3 vs The Wolverine
Thor Dark World vs Man of Steel
Captain America Winter Soldier vs The Amazing Spider-man 2
Guardians of the Galaxy vs X-men Days of Future Past
Avengers Age of Ultron vs Fantastic Four
Ant-man vs Deadpool
Captain America Civil War vs Batman vs Superman
Doctor Strange vs X-men Apocalypse
Guardians of the Galaxy 2 vs Justice League
Spider-man Homecoming vs Logan
Thor Ragnarok vs Wonder Woman
Black Panther vs Deadpool 2
Avengers Infinity War vs Incredibles 2
Ant-man and the Wasp vs Teen Titans Go to the Movies
I haven't seen Ant-man and the Wasp but there's no way I won't prefer it. So that's 12-8 in favour of the MCU.
|
|
|
|
Post by Vassaggo on Aug 15, 2018 1:16:38 GMT
13-7 MCU for me, but could've been easily 11-9 some are close.
|
|
|
|
Post by coldenhaulfield on Aug 15, 2018 1:34:30 GMT
Iron Man* vs The Dark Knight*
The Incredible Hulk* vs Punisher Warzone
Iron Man 2 vs X-men Origins Wolverine*
Thor vs X-men First Class***
Captain America vs Green Lantern [neither]
The Avengers*** vs The Dark Knight Rises*
Iron Man 3* vs The Wolverine*
Thor Dark World vs Man of Steel**
Captain America Winter Soldier vs The Amazing Spider-man 2*
Guardians of the Galaxy vs X-men Days of Future Past*
Avengers Age of Ultron vs Fantastic Four [neither]
Ant-man vs Deadpool
Captain America Civil War vs Batman vs Superman*
Doctor Strange vs X-men Apocalypse*
Guardians of the Galaxy 2 vs Justice League
Spider-man Homecoming vs Logan*
Thor Ragnarok vs Wonder Woman
Black Panther vs Deadpool 2 [neither]
Avengers Infinity War** vs Incredibles 2
Ant-man and the Wasp vs Teen Titans Go to the Movies [neither]
* = denotes theatrical viewing.
ETA: so that's -- what? 5-11-4 (MCU-Non-neither) for me.
|
|
|
|
Post by DC-Fan on Aug 15, 2018 1:59:27 GMT
Iron Man vs The Dark Knight
The Incredible Hulk vs Punisher Warzone PUSH
Iron Man 2 vs X-men Origins Wolverine PUSH
Thor vs X-men First Class
Captain America vs Green Lantern
The Avengers vs The Dark Knight Rises
Iron Man 3 vs The Wolverine PUSH
Thor Dark World vs Man of Steel
Captain America Winter Soldier vs The Amazing Spider-man 2
Guardians of the Galaxy vs X-men Days of Future Past
Avengers Age of Ultron vs Fantastic Four PUSH
Ant-man vs Deadpool
Captain America Civil War vs Batman vs Superman
Doctor Strange vs X-men Apocalypse
Guardians of the Galaxy 2 vs Justice League
Spider-man Homecoming vs Logan
Thor Ragnarok vs Wonder Woman
Black Panther vs Deadpool 2
Avengers Infinity War vs Incredibles 2
Ant-man and the Wasp vs Teen Titans Go to the Movies Haven't seen Teen Titans
|
|
|
|
Post by Nicko's Nose on Aug 15, 2018 2:05:14 GMT
Captain America Winter Soldier vs The Amazing Spider-man 2 Yeah you’re definitely not biased against the MCU... Yep... |
|
|
|
Post by Skaathar on Aug 15, 2018 2:08:08 GMT
Iron Man vs The Dark Knight
The Incredible Hulk vs Punisher Warzone PUSHIron Man 2 vs X-men Origins Wolverine PUSHThor vs X-men First Class
Captain America vs Green LanternThe Avengers vs The Dark Knight Rises
Iron Man 3 vs The Wolverine PUSHThor Dark World vs Man of Steel
Captain America Winter Soldier vs The Amazing Spider-man 2
Guardians of the Galaxy vs X-men Days of Future PastAvengers Age of Ultron vs Fantastic Four PUSH
Ant-man vs Deadpool
Captain America Civil War vs Batman vs Superman
Doctor Strange vs X-men Apocalypse
Guardians of the Galaxy 2 vs Justice LeagueSpider-man Homecoming vs LoganThor Ragnarok vs Wonder Woman
Black Panther vs Deadpool 2
Avengers Infinity War vs Incredibles 2
Ant-man and the Wasp vs Teen Titans Go to the Movies Haven't seen Teen TitansSo you preferred Green Lantern over CATFA. Good to know. |
|
|
|
Post by Nicko's Nose on Aug 15, 2018 2:13:50 GMT
Iron Man vs The Dark Knight
The Incredible Hulk vs Punisher Warzone
Iron Man 2 vs X-men Origins Wolverine
Thor vs X-men First Class
Captain America vs Green Lantern
The Avengers vs The Dark Knight Rises
Iron Man 3 vs The Wolverine
Thor Dark World vs Man of Steel
Captain America Winter Soldier vs The Amazing Spider-man 2
Guardians of the Galaxy vs X-men Days of Future Past
Avengers Age of Ultron vs Fantastic Four
Ant-man vs Deadpool
Captain America Civil War vs Batman vs Superman
Doctor Strange vs X-men Apocalypse
Guardians of the Galaxy 2 vs Justice League
Spider-man Homecoming vs Logan
Thor Ragnarok vs Wonder Woman
Black Panther vs Deadpool 2: Never seen them
Avengers Infinity War vs Incredibles 2: Not seen Incredibles 2
Ant-man and the Wasp vs Teen Titans Go to the Movies: Never seen them
MCU: 9
Non-MCU: 8
|
|
|
|
Post by coldenhaulfield on Aug 15, 2018 2:24:06 GMT
Iron Man vs The Dark KnightThe Incredible Hulk vs Punisher Warzone Iron Man 2 vs X-men Origins Wolverine Thor vs X-men First ClassCaptain America vs Green Lantern The Avengers vs The Dark Knight RisesIron Man 3 vs The Wolverine Thor Dark World vs Man of SteelCaptain America Winter Soldier vs The Amazing Spider-man 2 Guardians of the Galaxy vs X-men Days of Future PastAvengers Age of Ultron vs Fantastic Four Ant-man vs DeadpoolCaptain America Civil War vs Batman vs Superman Doctor Strange vs X-men Apocalypse Guardians of the Galaxy 2 vs Justice League Spider-man Homecoming vs LoganThor Ragnarok vs Wonder WomanBlack Panther vs Deadpool 2: Never seen themAvengers Infinity War vs Incredibles 2: Not seen Incredibles 2Ant-man and the Wasp vs Teen Titans Go to the Movies: Never seen themMCU: 9 Non-MCU: 8 Wow! Somehow the MCU managed to eke out a win. I'm stunned with shockness. |
|
|
|
Post by coldenhaulfield on Aug 15, 2018 2:25:26 GMT
Iron Man vs The Dark Knight
The Incredible Hulk vs Punisher Warzone PUSHIron Man 2 vs X-men Origins Wolverine PUSHThor vs X-men First Class
Captain America vs Green LanternThe Avengers vs The Dark Knight Rises
Iron Man 3 vs The Wolverine PUSHThor Dark World vs Man of Steel
Captain America Winter Soldier vs The Amazing Spider-man 2
Guardians of the Galaxy vs X-men Days of Future PastAvengers Age of Ultron vs Fantastic Four PUSH
Ant-man vs Deadpool
Captain America Civil War vs Batman vs Superman
Doctor Strange vs X-men Apocalypse
Guardians of the Galaxy 2 vs Justice LeagueSpider-man Homecoming vs LoganThor Ragnarok vs Wonder Woman
Black Panther vs Deadpool 2
Avengers Infinity War vs Incredibles 2
Ant-man and the Wasp vs Teen Titans Go to the Movies Haven't seen Teen TitansSo you preferred Green Lantern over CATFA. Good to know. Here's my take on both: CATFA is very bland and paint-by-numbers. It's really boring, and it shouldn't be because it has Red Skull in it, and he should've been a much bigger deal in hindsight. The first time I saw it felt like the tenth time I was sitting through it, although it did have a baseline level of quality and competency. Green Lantern, on the other hand, was just an abysmal piece of shit with effects so bad it was mildly amusing for at least... I'll say... five minutes. Then it was just torture. And what'shisname was god awful as the lead. So, it's like: I'm torn. That's all I've got. |
|
|
|
Post by Skaathar on Aug 15, 2018 3:52:31 GMT
Iron Man vs The Dark Knight
The Incredible Hulk vs Punisher Warzone
Iron Man 2 vs X-men Origins Wolverine
Thor vs X-men First Class - TIED
Captain America vs Green Lantern
The Avengers vs The Dark Knight Rises
Iron Man 3 vs The Wolverine
Thor Dark World vs Man of Steel
Captain America Winter Soldier vs The Amazing Spider-man 2
Guardians of the Galaxy vs X-men Days of Future Past - TIED
Avengers Age of Ultron vs Fantastic Four
Ant-man vs Deadpool
Captain America Civil War vs Batman vs Superman
Doctor Strange vs X-men Apocalypse
Guardians of the Galaxy 2 vs Justice League
Spider-man Homecoming vs Logan - TIED
Thor Ragnarok vs Wonder Woman
Black Panther vs Deadpool 2
Avengers Infinity War vs Incredibles 2
Ant-man and the Wasp vs Teen Titans Go to the Movies
So that's 14 for MCU, 3 for non-mcu and 3 tied.
|
|
moviemeisters
Sophomore
"Cinema is not a slice of life, but a piece of cake."
@moviemeisters
Posts: 193
Likes: 99
 
|
Post by moviemeisters on Aug 15, 2018 5:11:48 GMT
Iron Man vs The Dark KnightThe Incredible Hulk vs Punisher Warzone Iron Man 2 vs X-men Origins Wolverine Thor vs X-men First ClassCaptain America vs Green Lantern The Avengers vs The Dark Knight RisesIron Man 3 vs The Wolverine Thor Dark World vs Man of Steel Captain America Winter Soldier vs The Amazing Spider-man 2 Guardians of the Galaxy vs X-men Days of Future PastAvengers Age of Ultron vs Fantastic Four Ant-man vs Deadpool
Captain America Civil War vs Batman vs Superman Doctor Strange vs X-men Apocalypse Guardians of the Galaxy 2 vs Justice League Spider-man Homecoming vs LoganThor Ragnarok vs Wonder WomanBlack Panther vs Deadpool 2Avengers Infinity War vs Incredibles 2Ant-man and the Wasp vs Teen Titans Go to the Movies
MCU: 10 votes Non-MCU: 8 votes Pretty close!
|
|
|
|
Post by Nicko's Nose on Aug 15, 2018 5:34:05 GMT
Iron Man vs The Dark KnightThe Incredible Hulk vs Punisher Warzone Iron Man 2 vs X-men Origins Wolverine Thor vs X-men First ClassCaptain America vs Green Lantern The Avengers vs The Dark Knight RisesIron Man 3 vs The Wolverine Thor Dark World vs Man of SteelCaptain America Winter Soldier vs The Amazing Spider-man 2 Guardians of the Galaxy vs X-men Days of Future PastAvengers Age of Ultron vs Fantastic Four Ant-man vs DeadpoolCaptain America Civil War vs Batman vs Superman Doctor Strange vs X-men Apocalypse Guardians of the Galaxy 2 vs Justice League Spider-man Homecoming vs LoganThor Ragnarok vs Wonder WomanBlack Panther vs Deadpool 2: Never seen themAvengers Infinity War vs Incredibles 2: Not seen Incredibles 2Ant-man and the Wasp vs Teen Titans Go to the Movies: Never seen themMCU: 9 Non-MCU: 8 Wow! Somehow the MCU managed to eke out a win. I'm stunned with shockness. I honestly have no idea why you’d be so shocked. |
|
|
|
Post by coldenhaulfield on Aug 15, 2018 5:52:15 GMT
Wow! Somehow the MCU managed to eke out a win. I'm stunned with shockness. I honestly have no idea why you’d be so shocked. Because of artificial boosters. |
|
|
|
Post by DSDSquared on Aug 15, 2018 12:04:14 GMT
The toughest one for me is GOTG vs. DOFP. What a year for comic book movies. I love both so much. I chose DOFP, but still. Also, anyone who chooses TASM 2 over Winter Soldier is a troll and a moron. Seriously.
|
|
|
|
Post by Rey Kahuka on Aug 15, 2018 12:21:53 GMT
Iron Man vs The Dark Knight -- Tough matchup, gotta give it to TDK
The Incredible Hulk vs Punisher Warzone -- Neither was good, but War Zone was unwatchable.
Iron Man 2 vs X-men Origins Wolverine -- I enjoyed IM2 more than most, I think
Thor vs X-men First Class -- Easily my favorite X-Men team film
Captain America vs Green Lantern -- No contest
The Avengers vs The Dark Knight Rises -- The Avengers is an all time classic while TDKR is an embarrassment, so not much of a comparison there
Iron Man 3 vs The Wolverine -- I definitely enjoyed IM3 more than most, it's one of my favorite Marvel flicks.
Thor Dark World vs Man of Steel -- Draw, both were awful for their own reasons and I can't pick a winner
Captain America Winter Soldier vs The Amazing Spider-man 2 -- My favorite MCU film to date vs garbage you can't pay me to watch
Guardians of the Galaxy vs X-men Days of Future Past -- Guardians in a romp over an X-Men film every bit as awful as X3
Avengers Age of Ultron vs Fantastic Four -- AoU has its issues but I still think it's an excellent flick overall
Ant-man vs Deadpool -- Ant-Man was more fun than people give it credit for, but nowhere near as great as Deadpool
Captain America Civil War vs Batman vs Superman -- Civil War is overall a better film, despite my love for the insane Batman of BvS
Doctor Strange vs X-men Apocalypse -- A forgettable MCU flick vs. a film I wish I could forget
Guardians of the Galaxy 2 vs Justice League -- I didn't love Guardians 2, nor did I hate Justice League, but the edge goes to Guardians for the character beats
Spider-man Homecoming vs Logan -- No contest here
Thor Ragnarok vs Wonder Woman -- One of the hardest decisions on this list. Had to give it Ragnarok due to WW falling apart during the third act.
Black Panther vs Deadpool 2 -- Deadpool 2 didn't do anything to take things to the next level while BP gave us fresh ideas on world building in a CBM
Avengers Infinity War vs Incredibles 2 -- I2 was fun, but it doesn't compare to the perfect blend of drama, action and humor on display in IW
Ant-man and the Wasp vs Teen Titans Go to the Movies -- One of these was a goofy cartoon and the other was Teen Titans. Seriously though, had to go Ant-Man
|
|
|
|
Post by Rey Kahuka on Aug 15, 2018 12:43:52 GMT
The toughest one for me is GOTG vs. DOFP. What a year for comic book movies. I love both so much. I chose DOFP, but still. Also, anyone who chooses TASM 2 over Winter Soldier is a troll and a moron. Seriously. DC Fan for sure, but not anyone. For example, I hated DOFP. Hated it. I don't understand why people love it so much, but I don't think they're trolling when they choose it over Guardians, and I'm certainly not trolling by hating it. |
|
|
|
Post by DSDSquared on Aug 15, 2018 13:36:35 GMT
The toughest one for me is GOTG vs. DOFP. What a year for comic book movies. I love both so much. I chose DOFP, but still. Also, anyone who chooses TASM 2 over Winter Soldier is a troll and a moron. Seriously. DC Fan for sure, but not anyone. For example, I hated DOFP. Hated it. I don't understand why people love it so much, but I don't think they're trolling when they choose it over Guardians, and I'm certainly not trolling by hating it. That is fine, but in no world is TASM 2 even a decent movie while Winter Soldier is arguably the greatest MCU movie. |
|
|
|
Post by James on Aug 15, 2018 19:33:39 GMT
Iron Man vs The Dark Knight
The Incredible Hulk vs Punisher Warzone - Not seen Warzone
Iron Man 2 vs X-men Origins Wolverine - just BARELY
Thor vs X-men First Class
Captain America vs Green Lantern
The Avengers vs The Dark Knight Rises
Iron Man 3 vs The Wolverine
Thor Dark World vs Man of Steel
Captain America Winter Soldier vs The Amazing Spider-man 2
Guardians of the Galaxy vs X-men Days of Future Past
Avengers Age of Ultron vs Fantastic Four
Ant-man vs Deadpool
Captain America Civil War vs Batman vs Superman
Doctor Strange vs X-men Apocalypse
Guardians of the Galaxy 2 vs Justice League
Spider-man Homecoming vs Logan
Thor Ragnarok vs Wonder Woman
Black Panther vs Deadpool 2
Avengers Infinity War vs Incredibles 2
Ant-man and the Wasp vs Teen Titans Go to the Movies - Not seen either
MCU - 11
Non MCU - 7
MCU wins!
|
|
