NFL - Top 3 QBs

This is overblown and it all has to do with how much the media likes the player.  Pats fans used to complain about Peyton Manning yelling at his teammates when Brady does it just as much.  I always laugh when I see Brady chewing someone out after a play or directing them harshly at the line.  He's a QB, the team's coach on the field.  His job is to keep these guys focused and get the offense running to its maximum potential.  Hell, Brees bitched out a receiver who wasn't supposed to be in the huddle the other night, it was hilarious.      

Dude's a psycho

It's really hard to compare Quarterbacks and players in general that played in different times because the game has changed so much today. It's such a pass heavy league today and QB's are protected so much so who's to say a guy like Montana, Young, Marino, couldn't pass for 4,500+ yards and 35 TD's a year playing today? You almost need to make comparisons per decade. We're going to see shit get even worse going forward with how the league is going as well. All these stats and records are going to get demolished by guys because of how the league is played. I mean hell, Eli Manning is 6th in passing yards just behind Marino (who once had the record and has since been passed 3 times now) and 7th in TD passes yet I don't think he's ever really been considered one of the true best at his position by the masses. People today are even arguing whether or not he's a deserving Hall of Famer.

Makes things REALLY hard to compare different era players because of it. It's practically an entirely different game today than it was in the 80's. The only things in my mind that are really comparable over the decades are Championships won and MVP's.

Exactly and it's only going to get more insane as we have seen already this year with the high passing numbers. We'll have people saying that "so in so was better than Joe Montana, just look at how many more yards and touchdown's he threw than him" and so on. It just isn't a fair comparison in my mind. Yet we live in a time where everyone has to be compared to somebody and instead of just stating that it's your opinion people need to feel some sort of validation in there opinion being correct when in the end it's still just an opinion and not a fact. I get annoyed when people use Rotten Tomato's %'s as a form of "proving" whether or not a movie is good. All that proves is a % of critics that reviewed it are of the opinion that it is good. In the end opinions are still opinions and not facts.

The truth is, this question will never be solved. One person's top 3 will never be universally accepted as fact. It's just too impossible to compare for that to happen. Had everyone played in the same time frame with the same emphasis on the same rules then it could be an accurate discussion.

In the end I think hall of fame voters are going to have to have a real discussion on what Quarterbacks actually get into the hall of fame when so many of them will have such inflated passing totals.

It's easy for a QB when both he and his coach cheat all the fucking time. 
It's the one and only way to explain the Cheatriots success while other teams struggle. 

LOL. That’s almost as funny as an AFC Finalist banner!

I can see how a fan of a team that can’t get out of first gear, despite having a hemi under the hood, might think like that. Bitterness is a tough pill to swallow.

King Kong Shady just got owned!

Do you appreciate the irony of complaining about cheaters while using a Brewers logo as an avatar as much as I do?