|
Post by Martin Brundle - Martinfly on Mar 12, 2020 17:47:10 GMT
X2 is a masterpiece. I guess Scorsese has not seen it yet.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
@Deleted
Posts: 0
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 12, 2020 19:21:32 GMT
In the nicest (and I truly mean nicest possible way, since I know you like them a lot) I didn't know any of them were critically acclaimed. If they are, it's a gap in my knowledge, nothing to do with you.
I'll say Logan then.
|
|
thenolan
Sophomore
@thenolan
Posts: 778
Likes: 162
|
Post by thenolan on Mar 13, 2020 7:42:12 GMT
X2, DOFP, Logan, First Class.
|
|
|
Post by Martin Brundle - Martinfly on Mar 13, 2020 12:47:09 GMT
X2, DOFP, Logan, First Class. Good list. You're a true Marvel fan.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
@Deleted
Posts: 0
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 13, 2020 22:42:00 GMT
While I did choose Logan, I must give X2 its due and the credit it deserves. It was such an incredible comic book film and still holds up imo.
|
|
|
Post by dazz on Mar 14, 2020 6:07:58 GMT
In the nicest (and I truly mean nicest possible way, since I know you like them a lot) I didn't know any of them were critically acclaimed. If they are, it's a gap in my knowledge, nothing to do with you.
I'll say Logan then.
Not uncommon to be honest I think it's like calling something mediocre, most people don't know the actual meaning of the things, mediocre is seen as an insult and you are there by calling something bad, when it actually means average or ok, critically acclaimed actually just means it is mostly praised by critics, as in any movie on RT that has a fresh rating can be technically called critically acclaimed as it requires 60% of the critics they acknowledge to score the film a 6/10 or better, so good or higher, which means every MCU film is critically acclaimed, The Wolverine critically is the black sheep however, it only has a 71% on RT where as every other film listed is over 80% but they all count as critically acclaimed movies.
|
|
thenolan
Sophomore
@thenolan
Posts: 778
Likes: 162
|
Post by thenolan on Mar 14, 2020 10:17:49 GMT
In the nicest (and I truly mean nicest possible way, since I know you like them a lot) I didn't know any of them were critically acclaimed. If they are, it's a gap in my knowledge, nothing to do with you.
I'll say Logan then.
Not uncommon to be honest I think it's like calling something mediocre, most people don't know the actual meaning of the things, mediocre is seen as an insult and you are there by calling something bad, when it actually means average or ok, critically acclaimed actually just means it is mostly praised by critics, as in any movie on RT that has a fresh rating can be technically called critically acclaimed as it requires 60% of the critics they acknowledge to score the film a 6/10 or better, so good or higher, which means every MCU film is critically acclaimed, The Wolverine critically is the black sheep however, it only has a 71% on RT where as every other film listed is over 80% but they all count as critically acclaimed movies. I am pretty sure the people listing their favourites are not doing it by rotten tomatoes because rotten tomatoes is not a representation of acclaimed films. Nobody uses rotten tomatoes but you mcu kids, it is getting pathetic for the MCU Joker is the most acclaimed superhero film of 2019, RT does not show that but that is the fact. Deadpool was the most acclaimed film of 2016,RT does not show that but that is the fact. If you to show a movie was critically acclaimed, you would have to break the film down and talk about it artistically from a pure objective point, importantly the writing MCU will be the least acclaimed movies since their movies are the most childish and generic. X2 is a more acclaimed movie than any MCU movie just even for the reason it is an adult superhero film with more drama than disney can think off.
|
|
|
Post by dazz on Mar 14, 2020 11:21:02 GMT
Not uncommon to be honest I think it's like calling something mediocre, most people don't know the actual meaning of the things, mediocre is seen as an insult and you are there by calling something bad, when it actually means average or ok, critically acclaimed actually just means it is mostly praised by critics, as in any movie on RT that has a fresh rating can be technically called critically acclaimed as it requires 60% of the critics they acknowledge to score the film a 6/10 or better, so good or higher, which means every MCU film is critically acclaimed, The Wolverine critically is the black sheep however, it only has a 71% on RT where as every other film listed is over 80% but they all count as critically acclaimed movies. I am pretty sure the people listing their favourites are not doing it by rotten tomatoes because rotten tomatoes is not a representation of acclaimed films. Nobody uses rotten tomatoes but you mcu kids, it is getting pathetic for the MCU Joker is the most acclaimed superhero film of 2019, RT does not show that but that is the fact. Deadpool was the most acclaimed film of 2016,RT does not show that but that is the fact. If you to show a movie was critically acclaimed, you would have to break the film down and talk about it artistically from a pure objective point, importantly the writing MCU will be the least acclaimed movies since their movies are the most childish and generic. X2 is a more acclaimed movie than any MCU movie just even for the reason it is an adult superhero film with more drama than disney can think off. Being thicker than pigshit again I see, critical acclaim comes from critics positively reviewing a movie, this is something RT does represent and as far as I know is the largest movie review aggregator, it does not rate the movies it compiles the ratings of hundreds of critics who they themselves review the movie and RT posts the Tomatometer a mere thumbs up thumbs down ratio counter, as well as the average score from the compiled hundreds of professional reviews, Metacritic does this also but with smaller numbers but they also award critical acclaim to the overwhelming majority of MCU movies.
See RT atleast has some proof to what it posts, ie the actual reviews of all the reviews that it acknowledges, unlike you who simply spouts off opinion as fact, likely derived from a handful of sources you simply like and agree with rather than an attempt at a non-bias cross section of professional reviewers.
I mean if you have proof of your bold claims do please prove them, I highly doubt you though. seeing as you tend to speak almost exclusively out of your sphincter, unsurprising but still quite the feat given your cranium is stuck shoulder deep up there, so no wonder that's where you talk from, but the fact noise can escape such a place given the mountains of faecal sound proofing the sheer amount of bullshit you spew provides is regardless quite the marvel I would say.
|
|
|
Post by summers8 on Mar 14, 2020 16:38:41 GMT
1. Days of future past was my favourite for one reason. it completely showed Winter solider, what happens when another series is so seasoned making serious political thriller filled with compeeling characters versus another series that first attempted it.
2. Logan comes in second, since it was the first marvel film that many critics were willing to place above the dark knight
3. X1 comes in third, because the movie opening in nazi camps changed how comic films are viewed forever and even gave Nolan the guts to make the comic films he wanted.
The most acclaimed comic films tends to be the most intellectual comic films that critics only love xmen movies for.
|
|
|
Post by dazz on Mar 14, 2020 17:47:50 GMT
1. Days of future past was my favourite for one reason. it completely showed Winter solider, what happens when another series is so seasoned making serious political thriller filled with compeeling characters versus another series that first attempted it. 2. Logan comes in second, since it was the first marvel film that many critics were willing to place above the dark knight 3. X1 comes in third, because the movie opening in nazi camps changed how comic films are viewed forever and even gave Nolan the guts to make the comic films he wanted. The most acclaimed comic films tends to be the most intellectual comic films that critics only love xmen movies for. Eh nah brah that's the MCU films, according to RT MCU films make up part of the top 10, and the top 2 slots are MCU films, which have overwhelmingly positive reviews with almost 1000 reviews between them, only 1 FoX-Men movie is in the top 10 of all superhero movies in terms of critical acclaim, that being Logan at #7, there are 2 DC films on that top 10 list also Wonder woman at #4 and Shazam at #10, Spiderverse takes bronze at number 3 with the MCU films being Black Panther, Endgame, Homecoming, Far From Home & Ragnarok.
Now that is critical acclaim ie praise lavished by critics, public acclaim well that's kind of clear by box office, in which the MCU tops the charts again either individually or as a collective group, as they top the superhero lists as with 8 of the ten highest grossing superhero movies of all time and make up almost 1/3 or the 25 highest grossing films of all time, which has seen the MCU fanbase grow by leaps and bounds year by year where as DC is hit and miss, Fox was stagnated for the most part and Sony is on an upswing most recently partially due to their partnership with Marvel.
Now in terms of cultural acclaim I think Black Panther probably has that tied up, academic acclaim however I can see an argument being made for BP, Logan, TDK and Joker for their own reasons, but you accolades and such I would need to spend more time than I care to in order to properly research that, BP, Logan and Joker I can imagine are all films with a shit ton of accoladeswhich has most I however do not know.
But yeah the MCU dominates the acclaim in terms of critical acclaim and public acclaim as evident by their overwhelmingly positive and abundant reviews and healthy and long growing fanbase, but you keep saying how the acclaim goes to everyone else because YOU like other films more, I mean it makes you look like a mental patient but have at it mate, personally I think Logan is the best CBM ever made and is head and shoulders beyond any MCU film to date, but my opinion does not alter the facts that Endgame and Black Panther are the two most critically acclaimed CB/Superhero movies of all time, just doesn't I am afraid.
|
|
|
Post by summers8 on Mar 14, 2020 18:16:01 GMT
1. Days of future past was my favourite for one reason. it completely showed Winter solider, what happens when another series is so seasoned making serious political thriller filled with compeeling characters versus another series that first attempted it. 2. Logan comes in second, since it was the first marvel film that many critics were willing to place above the dark knight 3. X1 comes in third, because the movie opening in nazi camps changed how comic films are viewed forever and even gave Nolan the guts to make the comic films he wanted. The most acclaimed comic films tends to be the most intellectual comic films that critics only love xmen movies for. Eh nah brah that's the MCU films, according to RT MCU films make up part of the top 10, and the top 2 slots are MCU films, which have overwhelmingly positive reviews with almost 1000 reviews between them, only 1 FoX-Men movie is in the top 10 of all superhero movies in terms of critical acclaim, that being Logan at #7, there are 2 DC films on that top 10 list also Wonder woman at #4 and Shazam at #10, Spiderverse takes bronze at number 3 with the MCU films being Black Panther, Endgame, Homecoming, Far From Home & Ragnarok.
Now that is critical acclaim ie praise lavished by critics, public acclaim well that's kind of clear by box office, in which the MCU tops the charts again either individually or as a collective group, as they top the superhero lists as with 8 of the ten highest grossing superhero movies of all time and make up almost 1/3 or the 25 highest grossing films of all time, which has seen the MCU fanbase grow by leaps and bounds year by year where as DC is hit and miss, Fox was stagnated for the most part and Sony is on an upswing most recently partially due to their partnership with Marvel.
Now in terms of cultural acclaim I think Black Panther probably has that tied up, academic acclaim however I can see an argument being made for BP, Logan, TDK and Joker for their own reasons, but you accolades and such I would need to spend more time than I care to in order to properly research that, BP, Logan and Joker I can imagine are all films with a shit ton of accoladeswhich has most I however do not know.
But yeah the MCU dominates the acclaim in terms of critical acclaim and public acclaim as evident by their overwhelmingly positive and abundant reviews and healthy and long growing fanbase, but you keep saying how the acclaim goes to everyone else because YOU like other films more, I mean it makes you look like a mental patient but have at it mate, personally I think Logan is the best CBM ever made and is head and shoulders beyond any MCU film to date, but my opinion does not alter the facts that Endgame and Black Panther are the two most critically acclaimed CB/Superhero movies of all time, just doesn't I am afraid.
My entire reaction to this post.
MCU critical acclaim for the fun and the funny. Did we not expose once how black panther was a poor man xmen first class? Wasnt RT exposed as a sham with captain marvel last year. LMAO at mcu critical acclaim for the fun funny and jokes.
|
|
|
Post by blockbusted on Mar 14, 2020 19:00:58 GMT
Eh nah brah that's the MCU films, according to RT MCU films make up part of the top 10, and the top 2 slots are MCU films, which have overwhelmingly positive reviews with almost 1000 reviews between them, only 1 FoX-Men movie is in the top 10 of all superhero movies in terms of critical acclaim, that being Logan at #7, there are 2 DC films on that top 10 list also Wonder woman at #4 and Shazam at #10, Spiderverse takes bronze at number 3 with the MCU films being Black Panther, Endgame, Homecoming, Far From Home & Ragnarok.
Now that is critical acclaim ie praise lavished by critics, public acclaim well that's kind of clear by box office, in which the MCU tops the charts again either individually or as a collective group, as they top the superhero lists as with 8 of the ten highest grossing superhero movies of all time and make up almost 1/3 or the 25 highest grossing films of all time, which has seen the MCU fanbase grow by leaps and bounds year by year where as DC is hit and miss, Fox was stagnated for the most part and Sony is on an upswing most recently partially due to their partnership with Marvel.
Now in terms of cultural acclaim I think Black Panther probably has that tied up, academic acclaim however I can see an argument being made for BP, Logan, TDK and Joker for their own reasons, but you accolades and such I would need to spend more time than I care to in order to properly research that, BP, Logan and Joker I can imagine are all films with a shit ton of accoladeswhich has most I however do not know.
But yeah the MCU dominates the acclaim in terms of critical acclaim and public acclaim as evident by their overwhelmingly positive and abundant reviews and healthy and long growing fanbase, but you keep saying how the acclaim goes to everyone else because YOU like other films more, I mean it makes you look like a mental patient but have at it mate, personally I think Logan is the best CBM ever made and is head and shoulders beyond any MCU film to date, but my opinion does not alter the facts that Endgame and Black Panther are the two most critically acclaimed CB/Superhero movies of all time, just doesn't I am afraid.
My entire reaction to this post.
MCU critical acclaim for the fun and the funny. Did we not expose once how black panther was a poor man xmen first class? Wasnt RT exposed as a sham with captain marvel last year. LMAO at mcu critical acclaim for the fun funny and jokes.
1. You didn't expose anything, especially considering the fact that Black Panther DID make into AFI's Top 10 list at least one time. 2. RottenTomatoes doesn't write reviews, so what you're doing is shooting the messenger. 3. There are more people who gave a rating to Captain Marvel than people who gave a rating to Avengers: Infinity War. That's clearly not normal. Again, I must ask, what are you exactly trying to accomplish here? If you're trying to "enlighten" us by claiming that MCU is trash, it's clearly backfiring since all it's doing is turning a lot of people here into Fox X-Men haters. It's almost like you want another OdumC to happen.
|
|
|
Post by dazz on Mar 14, 2020 19:10:27 GMT
Eh nah brah that's the MCU films, according to RT MCU films make up part of the top 10, and the top 2 slots are MCU films, which have overwhelmingly positive reviews with almost 1000 reviews between them, only 1 FoX-Men movie is in the top 10 of all superhero movies in terms of critical acclaim, that being Logan at #7, there are 2 DC films on that top 10 list also Wonder woman at #4 and Shazam at #10, Spiderverse takes bronze at number 3 with the MCU films being Black Panther, Endgame, Homecoming, Far From Home & Ragnarok.
Now that is critical acclaim ie praise lavished by critics, public acclaim well that's kind of clear by box office, in which the MCU tops the charts again either individually or as a collective group, as they top the superhero lists as with 8 of the ten highest grossing superhero movies of all time and make up almost 1/3 or the 25 highest grossing films of all time, which has seen the MCU fanbase grow by leaps and bounds year by year where as DC is hit and miss, Fox was stagnated for the most part and Sony is on an upswing most recently partially due to their partnership with Marvel.
Now in terms of cultural acclaim I think Black Panther probably has that tied up, academic acclaim however I can see an argument being made for BP, Logan, TDK and Joker for their own reasons, but you accolades and such I would need to spend more time than I care to in order to properly research that, BP, Logan and Joker I can imagine are all films with a shit ton of accoladeswhich has most I however do not know.
But yeah the MCU dominates the acclaim in terms of critical acclaim and public acclaim as evident by their overwhelmingly positive and abundant reviews and healthy and long growing fanbase, but you keep saying how the acclaim goes to everyone else because YOU like other films more, I mean it makes you look like a mental patient but have at it mate, personally I think Logan is the best CBM ever made and is head and shoulders beyond any MCU film to date, but my opinion does not alter the facts that Endgame and Black Panther are the two most critically acclaimed CB/Superhero movies of all time, just doesn't I am afraid.
My entire reaction to this post.
MCU critical acclaim for the fun and the funny. Did we not expose once how black panther was a poor man xmen first class? Wasnt RT exposed as a sham with captain marvel last year. LMAO at mcu critical acclaim for the fun funny and jokes.
To answer your question no you did not expose BP as a poor First Class, you may think you did but ask the majority of people on here and they will likely tell you that you constantly fail at making any points because you are a deluded plonker.
No RT wasn't proven to be a sham last year with CM. if anything it proved the opposite as though it go mostly praise it actually scored under 7/10 as an aggregated score, this in spite of the likes of you throwing you toys out of your pram crying about how this is rigged, brought out yadda yadda yadda, btw CM was a mediocre movie imo so 6.8/10 seems a little high but not by much imo still no where near as good as most of the other cbm's we got last year it was literally the second worst one of 2019, the worst being Dark Phoenix.
But do go and try to prove how BP was a FC rip off, or anything you say, be nice if you could do that one of these days rather than running your mouth like a rat arsed lemming for a change.
|
|