Superman beats Thor in Fan Poll

Superman, Thor, Captain Marvel and Wonder Woman are all extremely powerful. Whoever wins would depend on who the writer gives the most plot armour to.

I'd say Superman and Wonder Woman were in the same league.

I think Supes has a better chance.

I get that, Superman was hit by a Nuke and he survived that. He's got super speed whereas Thor doesn't really move particulary fast in a fight or anything, even Quicksilver made him look like he was standing still.

Captain Marvel would be the better fight.

It all boils down to two things, which company is in charge of the story, and which writer have they hired, which is evident if you have read any Batman story in the last 30 years, fuck making sense Batman wins why because he's Batman...fuck Batman

Depends on more than that, depends on which version of Thor you are talking about, MCU Thor isn't magical, his mother, father & brother could use it but Thor is never shown actually having "magical" powers, his powers are just whatever they are similar to Kryptonians powers.

Also depends on which version of Superman you use, fucking dudes been given so many one off powers it's insane, also depends on what weakness's in total you give to each, sometimes Kryptonians breath in space or underwater fine other times they need suits, or at the least breathing apparatus, Thor I think is the same, also depends on what power level we set them at, Superman can tow planets in some instances and Thor can harness the Odin force, Superman can also weild Mjolnir and in some instances Thor reverts to human without it for too long.

All boils down to the whim of the writers which make these sort of thing fun but pointless because we can all just write any excuse out of  butts to justify the one we want to win.

Again depends on the writers, these aren't real people with set defined powers and abilities, at best we know their bare minimum power levels all versions must meet but nothing more, and ok Superman was allowed to use Mjlonir, Thor sometimes isn't allowed to wield it, again writers prerogative, if I was writing /I could write Superman can use Mjolnir and is capable of destroying it with a powerful clench of his butt cheeks whilst Thor can summon leprechauns with the power of rainbows that emanate from his peepee every time he self gratifies, if I am the writer what I says goes hence so many contradictions and stupid retcons in almost every characters history.

If we're only taking movie versions, I would have said Thor would win prior to Justice League. But Superman's powers got amped so much in that movie that he became boring.