I remember he was still pretty handsome in season 2 even though his face was supposed to be completely jacked. Jigsaw was supposed to look like a complete wreck and he didn't at all.
He was pretty. I liked his mask though.
I mean if you know the character, maybe you have expectations to be let down. I didn't know the character or even the actor. He threw me for a loop at the beginning but got better throughout season 1. By season 2 he was a full-blown threat. Even his scars were handsome but I liked the bit with the mask.