|
|
Post by mikef6 on Nov 27, 2019 19:07:33 GMT
Back in 1960 there is no way anybody could have forced me to see this movie in 1960. What!? A sentimental, simplistic, squeaky-clean, goody-goody Disney film for little kids? For a 15 year old tough guy like me? Uh-uh. BUT, when I finally did see it about 40 years later, it turned out that this is just the warmest, wisest, most wonderful movie about finding the good in everything. I was truly and authentically moved. This particular movie is much removed from the dark film noir I usually review on the weekly thread, I know. It is something of an anomaly with me, but I wanted to share it just for that reason. As written and directed by David Swift and acted by Haley Mills, Pollyanna is not the arrogant know-it-all that I was expecting. Neither was she sickly sweet. Instead, she is a girl who has experienced some tragedy and disruption in her own life but who remains upbeat and who makes simple, direct observations about what she sees. Karl Malden is tops among a cast of fine actors who react to Pollyanna’s straight talking with life changing results. Malden is the town’s fire and brimstone preacher (“DEATH COMES UNEXPECTEDLY!”) who learns that the “glad” verses in the Bible – passages about giving thanks, having joy, receiving mercy – far outnumber the wrath of God chapters. Close behind Malden is Adolphe Menjou as the recluse and local boogie man who lives in the “haunted house.” Pollyanna, though, is not impressed with his bluster. Agnes Moorehead is an extreme hypochondriac and Jane Wyman is Aunt Polly, the town’s nobility. Kevin “Moochie” Corcoran is not only tolerable, but good. The best he ever was. The open ending was not at all what I was looking for; it is totally unexpected. Discovering “Pollyanna” was an amazing experience. When I added this title to my alphabetical list of Best of 1960 I found that “Pollyanna” fell between “Plein Soleil” (Purple Noon) above and “Psycho” just below. She is nestled in between Tom Ripley and Norman Bates. Her work is cut out for her. The picture on this DVD cover makes Haley look a little scary. 
|
|
|
|
Post by amyghost on Nov 27, 2019 19:55:11 GMT
I like that review. I haven't seen this film in ages, but the little I can recall of it fits with your description that it wasn't candyfloss. I think Mills herself was probably, even at that age, a bit too clear-sighted to have given a portrayal of shallow, sticky-sweet goodness. It's actually surprising just how tough in some ways some of these Disney live-actioners were; one of my favorites was the Three Lives of Thomasina, another one that had the potential to be a rather gooey and sentimental tale of a young girl and her pet cat--and which is in reality a film that doesn't shy away from being actually quite grim and dark at moments.
|
|
|
|
Post by wmcclain on Nov 27, 2019 21:26:25 GMT
Pollyanna (1960), directed by David Swift. Still catching up on family films I missed when young, although I don't suppose many boys saw this one (voluntarily) at the time. An orphan girl moves in with her rich aunt who is a big wheel in her small town. Most everyone is strict and sour but, employing a positive outlook, a bit of matchmaking, and a talent for tactical disobedience, Pollyanna melts hard hearts and reforms the whole place. We have time for a weepie episode before the happy comeback. It's sweet but not as syrupy as I would have thought. Pollyanna is earnest and not at all smug or preachy, which would just kill the story. Great sets and a strong cast. Mostly I marvel at the natural talent of Hayley Mills in her second movie. She's 13 but looks younger. She did Tiger Bay (1959) the year before and in just eight more would be in Twisted Nerve (1968). Time flies. She did a slew of Disney films in between. It's over-long at 2 1/4 hours. The director was eager to cut 20 minutes and more but Disney, although he did not interfere with filming, had a hard time cutting; he fell in love with every scene and had to keep everything. The DVD has a commentary track with Mills and the director recorded 41 years later. Lavish praise for everyone involved:
- Karl Malden showed up two weeks early so he could rehearse his speeches off-contract. The director never had another actor do that.
- Malden said his scenes with Hayley starred "two noses".
- Walt Disney would cry during dailies. He took Hayley and her family to the park and rode all the rides with them.
- They had a hard time finding a Pollyanna until Mrs Disney and another studio wife saw Tiger Bay (1959) in London.
- The plot has a Lincoln quote engraved on a locket: "When you look for the bad in mankind, expecting to find it, you surely will." Months after the premier the director saw a Disneyland shop with thousands of the lockets for sale. He made them stop: the quote is fake, he'd just made it up.
- Mills, a growing girl at the time, still remembers the heaps of food available on the set. Quality eating time.

|
|
|
|
Post by spiderwort on Nov 28, 2019 0:24:55 GMT
Wonderful review, mike. And I, too, love this film for all the reasons you mention. It's a real treasure, one that I never miss the opportunity to view.
|
|
|
|
Post by snsurone on Nov 28, 2019 1:13:49 GMT
I'm sorry to be the Grinch on this thread, but I'm not crazy about this film. There are some good points, but I honestly believe that Hayley Mills was miscast. She was a British actress playing an American character, and her accent was off-putting, kinda like a juvenile Julie Andrews! The term "Pollyanna" has become synonymous with a goody two-shoes, and IMO, this movie did nothing to dispel that. And the bitter attitudes of most of the townspeople stemmed from their hatred of the cold, domineering Aunt Polly, who virtually owned the town. Admittedly, I haven't seen the movie in several years, but did she relinquish any control?
I'm not fond of Disney's live-action films; I greatly prefer his animated ones. My favorites (in no particular order):
SNOW WHITE AND THE SEVEN DWARFS PINOCCHIO FANTASIA (1940) LADY AND THE TRAMP BEAUTY AND THE BEAST THE LION KING
|
|
|
|
Post by teleadm on Nov 28, 2019 18:30:24 GMT
Me too, when I watched in the late 1980s, didn't think it would be anything for me, what interested me and made me watch it was the many well known actors who were in it. As the movie progressed I got more and more interested and in the end I was very much engaged in the story and cared about the characters. I'm seldom easy to manipulate, but this time I liked it.
|
|