Rate The Thor Films

Nov 12, 2017 11:30:16 GMT charzhino said:

Im interested in your ranking scores ArArArchStanton

I suppose I'd give them all 7's and 8's.  Ragnarok may go up, I'll have to see.

For me a 7 would mean I fully enjoyed it, it was well made and it didn't have any real drawbacks, but it's sort of the lowest amount of enjoyability and didn't have much that was extra impressive to get it any higher.

Nov 12, 2017 13:37:33 GMT Hauntedknight87 said:

Nov 12, 2017 1:25:08 GMT ArArArchStanton said:

In a very friendly way, can you help me understand why TDW earns a 3 for you? I just find it pretty enjoyable. I'm ok with saying I like most MCU films better, but I don't rate any of them a 3, so I'm just curious how your scale works.

Honestly? I thought it was terrible. From a story perspective it had a decent premise with the dark elves and Loki teaming up with Thor, but i thought the execution was poor. But to get to the main reason why i hated it:

1. Annoying and uninterested earth characters like Darcy, her intern and even Jane. Honestly jane probably the worst love interest ever introduced in the MCU and a complete waste of natalie portman, who by the way is actually not a bad actress. She's a wasted talent.

2. Lack of an interesting antagonist. Loki at least had charisma and a decent background, but Malekith? He was just boring. He seem like a fitting choice for Thanos Black Order, rather a main bad guy.


Again this is just my personal opinion.

Interesting.

I don't know anything about it I would define as terrible.  There were a ton of well acted and well shot scenes.  Even the ones with Darcy etc were well executed, even if you didn't like the concept or characters.

I actually found Malekith interesting.  I know he wasn't super complex, but the idea of an ancient race that existed before all others and who find people who live in the light of stars to be invasive species, is quite interesting IMO.

The Earth characters aren't my favorite, but they don't take the whole film down to a 3 IMO.