|
|
Post by summers8 on Oct 18, 2018 11:45:17 GMT
X-Men movies have bad cgi like all comics movies in their franchise but DOFP is not the xmen movie to go for for bad cgi, try origins and apocalypse. don't you see how stupid you made yourself look. you chose to ignore facts, you took dofp that has the most artistically praised comic fcgi scene ..maybe ever, aka the quicksilver scene that we did not stop hearing off to my irritation. that scene was so famous mcu killed their own quicksilver.
this is film technical art and it is not an opinion, it is fact as factual as trump is president, anyone denying that is just a fool who can't handle reality. if make this in film school you will get 4.0 GPA or higher.
the issue you pointed out is not really on several boards since that was not a mjaor criticism of the movie like it is with mcu movies. why do I keep defending the cgi in DOFP? No, I am defending the truth, facts and great film making. I will do that for any other film,
Let's face it. you finally cracked. you cant handle DOFP was a superior movie to every mcu movie in story and cgi. was called the best comic film since TDK. calling the CGI bad in DOFP is like saying batman begins is a worse reboot than batman forever and the cgi is as bad. sure that is your opinion but you wont have many to back you up, since many will go for facts not lies.
Logan made be a better film to some but logan and dofp are the best marvel moves ever made in this era. deal with that facts and move on. you are boring me.
Move on from what? My point is Logan is a better film and you keep going on some random rant about DOFP and critics. Logan is a superior film. I know this upsets you, like how The Dark Knight being a superior film also upset you. It's okay my friend. We got two great movies to celebrate together. the point is that you lied and kept on lying. DOFP does not have bad cgi and neither are they cartoonish or video game looking that is fact. also James Cameron was one of the directors advisers in the film, James nearly made an xmen movie himself in the 90s. dont you think he would have told bryan singer if dofp had problematic CGI to clean it up? and no James is not know for been a nice guy. he is brutal.
Please I hate mcu movies because of their bad or cartoon looking cgi, do you think I will like DOFP if it had the same problem too? I will hate it as much, maybe even more because as an xmen fan it will be too embarrassing and un-defendable.
someone calling logan a superior film to dofp upsetting me is like someone saying tdk is a superior film to batman begins is ipsetting me or spiderman 2 is a superior film to spiderman 1, also upsetting me. um, they dont.
I accept Logan, X2, DOFP are the gold standard for xmen, how anyone ranks them is not my business including when they choose to place fantastic alternatives like X-Men First Class and Deadpool 1 as the best xmen movie.
sorry.
|
|
|
|
Post by summers8 on Oct 18, 2018 11:48:05 GMT
funny thing about DOFP, I once said infinity war is a dumb down version of dofp because the story was lacking and the cgi looks too fake een with some plot similarities for both films.
how anyone can try and reverse that when the obvious truth is out there is too hilarious and ironic.
video game comic films..sure. they look like this.
even X-Men apocalypse did not look that fake
|
|
|
|
Post by Hauntedknight87 on Oct 18, 2018 11:59:24 GMT
Move on from what? My point is Logan is a better film and you keep going on some random rant about DOFP and critics. Logan is a superior film. I know this upsets you, like how The Dark Knight being a superior film also upset you. It's okay my friend. We got two great movies to celebrate together. the point is that you lied and kept on lying. DOFP does not have bad cgi and neither are they cartoonish or video game looking that is fact. also James Cameron was one of the directors advisers in the film, James nearly made an xmen movie himself in the 90s. dont you think he would have told bryan singer if dofp had problematic CGI to clean it up? and no James is not know for been a nice guy. he is brutal.
Please I hate mcu movies because of their bad or cartoon looking cgi, do you think I will like DOFP if it had the same problem too? I will hate it as much, maybe even more because as an xmen fan it will be too embarrassing and un-defendable.
someone calling logan a superior film to dofp upsetting me is like someone saying tdk is a superior film to batman begins is ipsetting me or spiderman 2 is a superior film to spiderman 1, also upsetting me. um, they dont. I accept Logan, X2, DOFP are the gold standard for xmen, how anyone ranks them is not my business including when they choose to place fantastic alternatives like X-Men First Class and Deadpool 1 as the best xmen movie. sorry.
You keep falsely accussing me of lying. The CGI looks bad to me. It may look better than Black Panther but it still looks like a video Game to me. Maybe, just maybe the studio should put more effort and money into making it look good. |
|
|
|
Post by bud47 on Oct 18, 2018 14:44:22 GMT
Wasn't this thread about DOFP vs Logan? How did this thread get derailed into the MCU versus these films? Oh right, summers8 as usual.
Logan is the better film. It is a more intimate and personal story with very touching performances and is most enjoyed when viewed as a standalone "Elsewords" type of film. DOFP is good as well, but it has more disappointing elements from a fan standpoint and has too many wasted characters that are relegated to cardboard cutouts with the sole focus once again placed on the fab-four (Xavier, Magneto, Mystique, Wolverine).
|
|
|
|
Post by blockbusted on Oct 18, 2018 22:25:54 GMT
Wasn't this thread about DOFP vs Logan? How did this thread get derailed into the MCU versus these films? Oh right, summers8 as usual. Logan is the better film. It is a more intimate and personal story with very touching performances and is most enjoyed when viewed as a standalone "Elsewords" type of film. DOFP is good as well, but it has more disappointing elements from a fan standpoint and has too many wasted characters that are relegated to cardboard cutouts with the sole focus once again placed on the fab-four (Xavier, Magneto, Mystique, Wolverine). Also, is summer8 even aware that the person who directed ‘War of the Worlds’ actually praised at least 2 MCU films? |
|
|
|
Post by summers8 on Oct 19, 2018 5:12:15 GMT
Wasn't this thread about DOFP vs Logan? How did this thread get derailed into the MCU versus these films? Oh right, summers8 as usual. Logan is the better film. It is a more intimate and personal story with very touching performances and is most enjoyed when viewed as a standalone "Elsewords" type of film. DOFP is good as well, but it has more disappointing elements from a fan standpoint and has too many wasted characters that are relegated to cardboard cutouts with the sole focus once again placed on the fab-four (Xavier, Magneto, Mystique, Wolverine). from a fan's point? I don't think so. many fans think it is the best movie. when you say from a fans point, that is usually mcu fans pretending to be xmen fans not actual xmen fans since xmen fans will compare it to the story and the comics factually.
what you call wasted characters is a lie since the oringal story only used certain characters in supporting roles. we were lucky we saw some characters making cameos because in the comics, they should be dead.
Once again, MCU fans are failing on xmen's lore, they call themselves fans of xmen and say the factual wrong things
also talk of wasted characters, wasnt this the main problem of nifty war, a 96% cgi movie where the characters hardy had a story arc, compared to DOFP where at least 4 characters had compelling drama driven arcs? which was more than even the comics since it was only kitty prdye that had a major compelling arc. i
see the differences? facts vs lies.
everything I said now, is backed up by the original story in the comics. what back you up?
|
|
