-The major consoles from 2000-2001 to date (NOTE: I used those dates because that's when things became Playstation vs XBox for the more serious type of gamer as after N64 I think Nintendo generally fell off in that regard as Nintendo became, as they say, more 'kiddie') = XBox (it's been my all around favorite)
-The major consoles prior to 2000-2001 = Nintendo (overall. as I would say NES/N64 etc helped make Nintendo my all around best)
but generally speaking... when it comes to more modern games(call it from around 2000 to date), a PC is far better since I tend to mostly like shooter variations which suit the PC best due to superiority of mouse+keyboard as it's just more natural/easier to track stuff on screen with a mouse than it is with a consoles analog stick (I am noticeably better with a mouse than a analog stick as a analog stick cripples me where as with a mouse I can play up to my potential and can track stuff on screen as good as I possibly can where as with a analog stick I can tell I am not up to a decent enough level to enjoy the typical shooter on a console). but putting shooter types of games aside, I would likely side with a console overall.
so given my answers above... I did not vote. but if you want me to vote based more on fairly recent memory ill definitely side with the PC overall. but I do notice that if you want more of a experience with games, it will naturally favor stuff more from the 3D era since they are much closer to a movie etc where as prior to the 3D-era, things could still be good but more in a challenging kind of way, or just for some quick action etc.
p.s. for the record... my #1 all-around video game experience to date = Mafia (2002) (on PC), which I consider a masterpiece. a word I rarely use. the 2nd game, while still one of the very top games I played, fell a bit short of the first one in terms of all around impact it left on me. in fact, I replayed Mafia (2002) (on PC(I used some tweaks like unlimited draw distance and aspect ratio fixes which make it display more properly on modern hardware at 1080p etc)) back in Aug 2018 as I finished the game on it's 16th anniversary and it's still top notch as the feeling at the end is something only high quality movies can achieve. I first played Mafia (2002) basically when it was new and replayed it here and there over the years since. hell, I will probably replay Mafia II (2010) (on PC) soon or probably no later than about a year from now I suspect. hell, Mafia II (2010) (on PC) was the reason I upgrade my GPU (video card) which at the time was a Radeon 5670 512MB which I had til July 2017 which you could say Mafia III (2016) was partially why I upgraded to my current GPU which is a Geforce 1050 Ti 4GB.
EDIT: I got 'Wine' setup on Linux Mint recently so I can use it to replay Mafia/Mafia II on Linux Mint instead of having to use Windows on the occasion I replay em.
Since 2009 I've had Nintendo's console and a Xbox. The only PlayStation I have is 2.
Last films watched: The Story of Louis Pasteur (1936) 9/10 Dr. Strangelove (1964) 10/10 Killer Klowns from Outer Space (1988) 6/10 Manhunter (1986) 10/10 Evangelion 2.22: You Can (Not) Advance (2009) 8/10