Post by hairybuttcheeks on Mar 19, 2017 18:50:13 GMT
Romo! We are both Giants fans. Last night we were talking about tony and be kept ripping him, saying nobody will pick him up.
So i pointed out tony has a better comp %, yards PP, TD/INT, QB rating, etc. His argument is eli has been healthy and racked up more stats, tony doesn't count because he didn't start enough. i pointed out tony started 127 games and eli 199. 127 is more than a big enough sample size! The difference between eli and tonys games started is over 3 seasons.
after i tore down his argument that eli's all time passing yards and touchdowns makes him better, he said you can't compare them. so i said "you can't compare any players because they didn't have that same amount of playing time? pass attempts? at bats? innings? what kind of sense does that makes?"
then he said at the end of the day they will remember who has 2 rings. but rings are a team accomplishment - with that logic, you can say andy pettite is better than pedro?!?!?! pettite has the most all time postseason wins and 5 rings, pedro has 1. but pedro is much better.
he is so biased. we both hate the cowboys, but at least i can admit tony is better than eli
So i pointed out tony has a better comp %, yards PP, TD/INT, QB rating, etc. His argument is eli has been healthy and racked up more stats, tony doesn't count because he didn't start enough. i pointed out tony started 127 games and eli 199. 127 is more than a big enough sample size! The difference between eli and tonys games started is over 3 seasons.
after i tore down his argument that eli's all time passing yards and touchdowns makes him better, he said you can't compare them. so i said "you can't compare any players because they didn't have that same amount of playing time? pass attempts? at bats? innings? what kind of sense does that makes?"
then he said at the end of the day they will remember who has 2 rings. but rings are a team accomplishment - with that logic, you can say andy pettite is better than pedro?!?!?! pettite has the most all time postseason wins and 5 rings, pedro has 1. but pedro is much better.
he is so biased. we both hate the cowboys, but at least i can admit tony is better than eli