Deleted
Deleted Member
@Deleted
Posts: 0
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 8, 2018 1:23:19 GMT
I disagree with the OP that "they are all the same". Just not true. Most of the MCU movies do have a very similar / tired/ cookie cutter formula to them (thanks Kevin Feige!) but at least with some of the X Men movies & DC they have different tones & bring different ideas to the table imo (you can't tell me the Dark Knight trilogy is similar in any way to say Ant Man or those gawd awful Thor movies) .
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
@Deleted
Posts: 0
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 8, 2018 2:08:49 GMT
I do wonder when the genre will hit the wall. They are all the same and there are so many now as well which kind of cheapens it a little or makes it less special.
Then when you factor in that they reboot these films now every few years in some cases you just have to wonder what the point is. Asides from making them huge amounts of cash of course.
|
|
|
Post by jonesjxd on Oct 10, 2018 22:31:36 GMT
For the same reason people piled into theaters to watch westerns, biblical epics, war movies, alien invasion movies, giant insect movies, monster movies, asteroid movies, shipwreck movies, etc. Life gets mundane at times, it gets stressful, it gets sad, or it gets too hot, or too cold, and people need to go someplace and escape those things for a few hours. People want to see something big, broad, funny, adventurous, lively, colorful, out of this world, at this moment in movie history that's superhero movies, and Star Wars, and Fast & Furious. Some are really good, the Marvel movies will provide you a good 2 + hours of disposable fun and excitement, that's why they're successful, others are bad and tons of people don't go see them.
|
|
|
Post by Feologild Oakes on Oct 10, 2018 22:51:11 GMT
Well you know it could be i don`t know..........because they like superhero movies.
Or the secret shadow government is paying them to watch them.
One of those
|
|
|
Post by amyghost on Oct 10, 2018 22:52:58 GMT
Beats me. It's like wanting to eat a diet composed of nothing but cotton candy. Cotton candy is dandy as an occasional treat, but the very thought of eating virtually nothing but is perplexing and pretty sickening. But it appears that a lot of people want to consume nothing much but that, cinema-wise. Maybe it's for lack of being nurtured on a better diet.
|
|
|
Post by Nalkarj on Oct 10, 2018 23:00:44 GMT
I always respect your judgment, Aussie, but you’ve got to know that blanket-statement simply isn’t true, any more than saying “all westerns are the same” or “all romances are the same.” There are good movies and bad movies in this genre, as there are in every genre. It is true that some of these Marvel movies that come out every single year are formulaic, but even there we have some redeeming factors. There’s a good deal of cleverness in Iron Man, Captain America, and The Winter Soldier (to name three of the Marvel flicks)—they’re what Roger Ebert called “real movies,” driven by intelligent plotting and sympathetic characterization, not lights-and-effects shows with characters shoehorned in. If you don’t like superheroes and find them childish, that’s fine—but it’s difficult to deny that these movies, for example, aren’t “the same” and are genuinely thoughtful, made for discerning audiences. The ur-example of “superhero movie made for discerning audience” is, of course, The Dark Knight (2008). That film uses an inherently silly concept—the figure of Batman—to address real-life concerns and show excellent filmmaking. (I don’t think it’s as successful as its predecessor, Batman Begins, but mine is a minority opinion.) So many stories we love are silly and, yes, even “childish,” from the adventures of Indiana Jones and Luke Skywalker to the Universal horror films to classics I know you and I love, Aussie. I don’t deny that there are way too many superhero movies nowadays and that the obsession with them is insane. But there are still diamonds in the rough, “real movies,” and they’re worth seeking out and watching for the same reason we watch Jones, Skywalker, and Dorothy skipping down the Yellow Brick Road—and for the same reason that we read about Classical gods and monsters, archetypes in whom we can see ourselves even in part.
|
|
|
Post by sostie on Oct 10, 2018 23:26:10 GMT
Because I grew up reading comics and still collect vintage ones, and its great to see them on screen.
I don't think any Comic Book Movie would make my top 10 films. And I don't only watch comic book films. But some of the most enjoyable films I've seen on the big screen in recent years were comic book movies. There are certainly some crap ones, but when they are good, for me, they are top blockbuster entertainment.
If you don't like them don't watch them. Simple. And by not watching them, it doesn't make you any better than those that do.
|
|
Harmless elf
Junior Member
I'm a slick shyster the pest Meister
@amiable
Posts: 2,924
Likes: 1,171
|
Post by Harmless elf on Oct 11, 2018 0:46:47 GMT
Well you can't deny they have the best production. just that thanos Gauntlet itself lighting up and the sound effects coming from it there's more work put into that then most movies. It's the same reason people see Disney movies and the Pixar movies they just have the best production. Also you could argue that any genre of movie is all the same.
|
|
Flynn
Sophomore
@flynn
Posts: 515
Likes: 270
|
Post by Flynn on Oct 11, 2018 1:34:37 GMT
I can't tell you why people love superhero movies, but I can tell you this. I love slasher movies. And it doesn't matter that they are all the same. In fact, I'm annoyed when a slasher tries to be different. The more generic they are the better. There's an 80% chance I'll love any film with this plot description: A group of college friends get together [for fill-in-the-blank activity] and are killled off one by one by a masked killer until the final girl fights back and stops the killer's reign of terror. My point is: my love of slashers is all about the vibe. It's the atmosphere that I love. Well, that and the narrative structure. And no amount of bad acting, poor scripting, or bad special effects will get in the way. It may even enhance my love. I imagine people love superhero movies for similar reasons. They like the genericism. There's just something about superheros that resonates with them. I don't like superhero movies. I think they're dumb, boring, and pointless. But most people would say the same thing about slashers. And that's why I have to recognize that people are loving something I can't see in or feel from these movies, just as I see and feel something different with slashers.
|
|