|
|
Post by Skaathar on Jun 19, 2019 17:59:22 GMT
Pick 1 winner from each of the matches (movie which you prefer) and vote in the poll above. Make sure you only vote for 1 winner per match. If you need to make a tie, don't vote on that particular match... though I encourage you to vote for every match as this helps the statistics.
Round 17
Match 1: Superman vs. Steel
Match 2: Catwoman vs. Batman & Robin
Match 3: Constantine vs. Batman Forever
Match 4: Batman Begins vs. Batman Returns
Match 5: Superman Returns vs. Batman (89)
Match 6: The Dark Knight vs. V for Vendetta
Match 7: Watchmen vs. Superman IV
Match 8: Jonah Hex vs. Supergirl
Match 9: Green Lantern vs. Superman III
Match 10: TDKR vs. Swamp thing
Match 11: Man of Steel vs. Superman II
Match 12: BvS vs. Shazam
Match 13: Suicide Squad vs. Aquaman
Match 14: Wonder Woman vs. Justice League
|
|
|
|
Post by thisguy4000 on Jun 19, 2019 18:06:28 GMT
I haven’t been following these polls up to now, but I am curious about something. Are these polls meant to figure out what DC movie people think is the absolute best of the best?
|
|
|
|
Post by Skaathar on Jun 19, 2019 18:08:26 GMT
I haven’t been following these polls up to now, but I am curious about something. Are these polls meant to figure out what DC movie people think is the absolute best of the best? Well that's part of it. Mostly it's a way to figure out the overall rankings of these movies as far as the regulars here perceive it to be. That way we have a ranking system based on the cumulative opinions of the posters here.
|
|
|
|
Post by thisguy4000 on Jun 19, 2019 18:11:01 GMT
I haven’t been following these polls up to now, but I am curious about something. Are these polls meant to figure out what DC movie people think is the absolute best of the best? Well that's part of it. Mostly it's a way to figure out the overall rankings of these movies as far as the regulars here perceive it to be. That way we have a ranking system based on the cumulative opinions of the posters here. So, are you comparing each individual movie with one another? In other words, TDK to B&R, WW to Halle Berry’s CW, etc.?
|
|
|
|
Post by Skaathar on Jun 19, 2019 18:18:45 GMT
Well that's part of it. Mostly it's a way to figure out the overall rankings of these movies as far as the regulars here perceive it to be. That way we have a ranking system based on the cumulative opinions of the posters here. So, are you comparing each individual movie with one another? In other words, TDK to B&R, WW to Halle Berry’s CW, etc.? Correct. It's a round robin tournament where each movie will need to compete with every other movie. Everytime a movie wins in one of the matches, it earns 1 point. Then the movies get arranged in rank by their total points. If I was simply after the best DC movie, I would have employed an elimination-type of match. Far simpler and quicker. But because I wanted to get proper rankings, I decided to go with a round robin tournament. It's long and a bit exhausting but a lot more accurate.
|
|
|
|
Post by thisguy4000 on Jun 19, 2019 18:21:21 GMT
So, are you comparing each individual movie with one another? In other words, TDK to B&R, WW to Halle Berry’s CW, etc.? Correct. It's a round robin tournament where each movie will need to compete with every other movie. Everytime a movie wins in one of the matches, it earns 1 point. Then the movies get arranged in rank by their total points. If I was simply after the best DC movie, I would have employed an elimination-type of match. Far simpler and quicker. But because I wanted to get proper rankings, I decided to go with a round robin tournament. It's long and a bit exhausting but a lot more accurate. It certainly sounds like you have your work cut out for you.
|
|
|
|
Post by Skaathar on Jun 19, 2019 18:23:58 GMT
Correct. It's a round robin tournament where each movie will need to compete with every other movie. Everytime a movie wins in one of the matches, it earns 1 point. Then the movies get arranged in rank by their total points. If I was simply after the best DC movie, I would have employed an elimination-type of match. Far simpler and quicker. But because I wanted to get proper rankings, I decided to go with a round robin tournament. It's long and a bit exhausting but a lot more accurate. It certainly sounds like you have your work cut out for you. It was pretty successful in the MCU board when I did the MCU rankings. There are less people in the DC board plus more movies so it's a bit more tedious, but ah well, it helps give this board a bit of activity.
|
|
|
|
Post by James on Jun 19, 2019 19:44:47 GMT
Match 1: Superman vs. Steel
Match 2: Catwoman vs. Batman & Robin
Match 3: Constantine vs. Batman Forever
Match 4: Batman Begins vs. Batman Returns
Match 5: Superman Returns vs. Batman (89)
Match 6: The Dark Knight vs. V for Vendetta
Match 7: Watchmen vs. Superman IV
Match 8: Jonah Hex vs. Supergirl
Match 9: Green Lantern vs. Superman III
Match 10: TDKR vs. Swamp thing
Match 11: Man of Steel vs. Superman II
Match 12: BvS vs. Shazam
Match 13: Suicide Squad vs. Aquaman
Match 14: Wonder Woman vs. Justice League
|
|
|
|
Post by Archelaus on Jun 22, 2019 22:25:15 GMT
Match 1: Superman vs. Steel
Match 2: Catwoman vs. Batman & Robin
Match 3: Constantine vs. Batman Forever
Match 4: Batman Begins vs. Batman Returns
Match 5: Superman Returns vs. Batman (89)
Match 6: The Dark Knight vs. V for Vendetta
Match 7: Watchmen vs. Superman IV
Match 8: Jonah Hex vs. Supergirl
Match 9: Green Lantern vs. Superman III
Match 10: TDKR vs. Swamp thing
Match 11: Man of Steel vs. Superman II
Match 12: BvS vs. Shazam
Match 13: Suicide Squad vs. Aquaman
Match 14: Wonder Woman vs. Justice League
|
|
