|
Post by mstreepsucks on Sept 27, 2021 5:32:37 GMT
I'm not sure if anyone would agree with me or not on this. This is the scene where han solo dies. The problem with it is the characters react as if it's a big deal to them when it isn't. Those besides chewbacca.
You know the scene when boba fet dies and the scene where jengo fet dies in attack of the clones? Well imagine if the han solo death was done in that way it would have had more weight atatched to it than what we got.
At least i would imagine so. It could have been done much better if the director actually tried. That's the main problem it seems the director of it didn't even try.
Because there's some unnecessary fanfar that goes with it. Just like there was some unnecessary fanfare with the appearance of luke. It's the same thing basically, like imagine if luke showed up with no fanfare whatsoever.
So it's like they either have to have the fanfare when a character is killed or when another is showing up but the fanfare is for no logical reason.
Not sure if this made much sense really.
|
|
|
Post by Midi-Chlorian_Count on Sept 27, 2021 9:53:40 GMT
To be honest I'm not sure if Han Solo having his head chopped off would have been any better than what we got. Ok maybe Kylo sadly holding up his head would have been nice visually but then it would have been him who'd cut it off in the first place so it could have played out looking a bit daft.
Having said that, Kylo killing Han at all was always going to play out as looking daft and is purely as a result of cookie cuttering Han into the Obi Wan role in this film. The Vader vs Obi Wan rivalry simply doesn't exist as they are father / son.
|
|
|
Post by onethreetwo on Sept 30, 2021 5:23:31 GMT
I agree that JJ is a tryhard hack.
|
|
|
Post by Power Ranger on Oct 1, 2021 16:04:39 GMT
Agreed. It would have been more haunting if the characters’ reactions were muted, except with an anguished cry from Chewie.
I’ve always thought that the scene was too long. There was too much build up that everyone knew as he held the lightsaber that he would die. If it was much quicker it would have been more surprising.
|
|