lune7000
Junior Member
@lune7000
Posts: 1,091
Likes: 678
|
Post by lune7000 on Oct 10, 2021 2:04:54 GMT
Ever notice that almost no movie mostly takes place in a hospital? Among classic films, this is even more rare. I remember Bad for Each Other and Kiss and Make Up but that's about it. And in reality, these two movies were based more in the doctor's office than the main floors or patient rooms of a hospital. Sure, lots of movies have a quick scene or two in a hospital but it is very rare for any movie to use a hospital as a main set.
Considering how many people work in hospitals and how many important life turning points occur there, it's curious that movies avoid the setting. Far more movies are set on a Broadway stage- and how many of us have ever been there?
|
|
|
Post by OldAussie on Oct 10, 2021 2:10:51 GMT
|
|
|
Post by OldAussie on Oct 10, 2021 2:11:42 GMT
|
|
|
Post by mikef6 on Oct 10, 2021 3:02:20 GMT
The Hasty Heart (1949). Set in a military hospital in Burma during WWII (I wonder if they called them M*A*S*H units then). Good acting from Ronald Reagan, Patricia Neal, and Richard Todd at a Scot who is dying but doesn't know it.
|
|
|
Post by mattgarth on Oct 10, 2021 4:26:53 GMT
Marlon Brando's film debut in 1950 -- THE MEN -- takes place in a veterans hospital.
|
|
frogarama
Freshman
I actually thought Prometheus both sucked and blowed.
@frogarama
Posts: 53
Likes: 25
|
Post by frogarama on Oct 10, 2021 8:33:43 GMT
One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest.
I believe it's quite well known.
|
|
|
Post by timshelboy on Oct 10, 2021 19:00:12 GMT
|
|
lune7000
Junior Member
@lune7000
Posts: 1,091
Likes: 678
|
Post by lune7000 on Oct 10, 2021 21:11:51 GMT
And these posts just prove my point. Movies have been around for 100 years and this is all there is?
Meanwhile, TV got started with Dr. Kildare, General Hospital, Marcus Welby M.D. and has continued powering through hospital based shows ever since with things like ER, St. Elsewhere, House MD, The Good Doctor, and over 50 other series.
It's no comparison really- and that is if I am being charitable and allowing military based movies like Hasty Heart and Mash which were as much war movies as medical movies. (and don't start throwing in mental ward stuff like Cuckoo's Nest b/c that is not the same thing)
Why Hollywood hates hospitals I don't know.
|
|
|
Post by Captain Spencer on Oct 10, 2021 21:38:19 GMT
|
|
|
Post by Catman on Oct 10, 2021 21:57:43 GMT
Red Beard is set in a clinic.
|
|
|
Post by Rufus-T on Oct 10, 2021 22:25:00 GMT
|
|
|
Post by phantomparticle on Oct 10, 2021 22:46:13 GMT
Green for Danger (1946, Britain) Murder mystery set in an emergency hospital during WWII.
|
|
|
Post by london777 on Oct 10, 2021 23:30:16 GMT
Brink of Life (NΓ€ra livet) (1958) dir: Ingmar Bergman IMDb says: Three women in a maternity ward reveal their lives and intimate thoughts to each other while in a maternity ward together, where they face the choice of keeping their babies or offering them for adoption.One of the very few Bergman films I have never seen and have no interest in seeing. The reason? It is set in a hospital. Ghastly places.
|
|
|
Post by london777 on Oct 10, 2021 23:41:51 GMT
Britannia Hospital (1982) dir: Lindsay Anderson
|
|
|
Post by london777 on Oct 10, 2021 23:56:40 GMT
The Kingdom (Riget), TV Series (1994β1997), dir: Lars von Trier and others. A black comedic horror/fantasy/satire, maybe the best work mentioned in this thread.
|
|
lune7000
Junior Member
@lune7000
Posts: 1,091
Likes: 678
|
Post by lune7000 on Oct 11, 2021 2:07:32 GMT
I can help you against my own thread by throwing in Patch Adams but the title of the thread is NOT MANY movies in hospitals. I did NOT write NO movies in hospitals. Movies have been around for 100 years and the number of films listed here so far in paltry for that volume. Plus people are stretching the definition by throwing in mental hospitals, war hospitals, etc.
Now compare this to TV land where the good old fashioned hospital we all use is a regular staple of every network every year for as long as TV has been around- the difference is staggering and I don't think anyone can seriously argue this point.
So my question to you is why? Why has hospital based drama been the province of TV not movies?
|
|
|
Post by Doghouse6 on Oct 11, 2021 3:08:07 GMT
I can help you against my own thread by throwing in Patch Adams but the title of the thread is NOT MANY movies in hospitals. I did NOT write NO movies in hospitals. Movies have been around for 100 years and the number of films listed here so far in paltry for that volume. Plus people are stretching the definition by throwing in mental hospitals, war hospitals, etc. Now compare this to TV land where the good old fashioned hospital we all use is a regular staple of every network every year for as long as TV has been around- the difference is staggering and I don't think anyone can seriously argue this point. So my question to you is why? Why has hospital based drama been the province of TV not movies?By way of answers, I submit an anecdote that may provide a hint. In late 1933, director Frank Capra had a script in which he very much believed, titled Night Bus. Columbia exec Harry Cohn was dead set against it. But when a big male star from a different studio became available for loan-out, and an equally big female star from another agreed on the condition of an accelerated production schedule so her holiday plans wouldn't be disrupted, Cohn grudgingly relented in spite of his boilerplate reasoning: "Nobody wants bus pictures. They always lose money." (I note in passing that the film was retitled just before its Feb '34 release: It Happened One Night.) It's only a guess, but it may have been as simple as that: "conventional wisdom" among producers and execs that hospital pictures weren't box office. Of course, that wouldn't stop a going concern like MGM from occasionally dipping a toe in what might have been considered a risky genre. That same male star's very next film back at his home studio was 1934's Men In White, which took place almost entirely within the confines of a large metropolitan hospital. And a studio with the prolific annual output of MGM could afford a certain percentage of gambles each year, as well as collections of modestly-priced B features like the Dr. Kildare series. At other studios, hospital-centric pictures were more often than not equally budget-conscious Bs, like Warners' 1936 The Murder of Dr. Harrigan and 1938's The Patient in Room 18 (which were, like phantomparticle 's submission, Green For Danger, hospital-centered whodunits). While there continued to be occasional big-screen visitations, like 1956's efficient Emergency Hospital and 1961's quite good The Young Doctors, perhaps the answer to your second question is that the intimacy of such human dramas was felt to be more suited to the equally intimate, small-screen home-viewing experience. Still, if memory serves, hospital TV dramas had lost their popularity by the close of the '60s other than for daytime drama, and didn't become trendy again in prime-time until the 1980s/'90s.
|
|
|
Post by phantomparticle on Oct 11, 2021 9:23:55 GMT
No one is stretching anything, since you did not rule out mental hospitals or war hospitals in your opening post. And they are hospitals.
In my own submission, Green For Danger, the entire movie takes place in the emergency hospital, with the exception of a brief scene explaining why a particular patient needs to be admitted and a few minutes of conversation during a staff dance just off the hospital grounds.
If you are going to complain that the answers are running far afield of your original question, then I suggest you be more specific about your restrictions in your opening statement.
|
|
|
Post by Rufus-T on Oct 11, 2021 15:32:35 GMT
I do find it peculiar you picked hospital. That aren't that many movies, if any, take place mostly in the supermarket or grocery store, in park, inside the cinema either. Other than My Diner with Andre, I don't know any other movie that takes place mostly inside a restaurant. Okay, maybe Ratatouille. Lots of people in those places too.
|
|
lune7000
Junior Member
@lune7000
Posts: 1,091
Likes: 678
|
Post by lune7000 on Oct 11, 2021 19:40:14 GMT
I can help you against my own thread by throwing in Patch Adams but the title of the thread is NOT MANY movies in hospitals. I did NOT write NO movies in hospitals. Movies have been around for 100 years and the number of films listed here so far in paltry for that volume. Plus people are stretching the definition by throwing in mental hospitals, war hospitals, etc. Now compare this to TV land where the good old fashioned hospital we all use is a regular staple of every network every year for as long as TV has been around- the difference is staggering and I don't think anyone can seriously argue this point. So my question to you is why? Why has hospital based drama been the province of TV not movies?By way of answers, I submit an anecdote that may provide a hint. In late 1933, director Frank Capra had a script in which he very much believed, titled Night Bus. Columbia exec Harry Cohn was dead set against it. But when a big male star from a different studio became available for loan-out, and an equally big female star from another agreed on the condition of an accelerated production schedule so her holiday plans wouldn't be disrupted, Cohn grudgingly relented in spite of his boilerplate reasoning: "Nobody wants bus pictures. They always lose money." (I note in passing that the film was retitled just before its Feb '34 release: It Happened One Night.) It's only a guess, but it may have been as simple as that: "conventional wisdom" among producers and execs that hospital pictures weren't box office. Of course, that wouldn't stop a going concern like MGM from occasionally dipping a toe in what might have been considered a risky genre. That same male star's very next film back at his home studio was 1934's Men In White, which took place almost entirely within the confines of a large metropolitan hospital. And a studio with the prolific annual output of MGM could afford a certain percentage of gambles each year, as well as collections of modestly-priced B features like the Dr. Kildare series. At other studios, hospital-centric pictures were more often than not equally budget-conscious Bs, like Warners' 1936 The Murder of Dr. Harrigan and 1938's The Patient in Room 18 (which were, like phantomparticle 's submission, Green For Danger, hospital-centered whodunits). While there continued to be occasional big-screen visitations, like 1956's efficient Emergency Hospital and 1961's quite good The Young Doctors, perhaps the answer to your second question is that the intimacy of such human dramas was felt to be more suited to the equally intimate, small-screen home-viewing experience. Still, if memory serves, hospital TV dramas had lost their popularity by the close of the '60s other than for daytime drama, and didn't become trendy again in prime-time until the 1980s/'90s. This makes sense
|
|