|
Post by Carl LaFong on Feb 25, 2022 23:13:08 GMT
My gut response on hearing that the BBC was planning a new adaptation of Great Expectations with Olivia Colman was much the same as Brenda from Bristol’s on hearing there was to be a general election in 2017. Not another one. Nothing against the book or Colman – I’m sure she will make a wonderful Miss Havisham – but the BBC seem to remake Great Expectations every five to 10 years. So how about trying something new? A while later, I noticed on Twitter that the author Philip Hensher felt much the same way and, as he is much better read than me, I asked him what books that had been overlooked he would like to see serialised for TV. Here’s his selection. If you’re determined to stay with Charles Dickens, it’s been a while since either The Pickwick Papers – Toby Jones would be a great Mr Pickwick – and The Old Curiosity Shop have been adapted. And Mrs Lirriper’s Christmas stories would make a fabulous 19th-century “Keeping Up Appearances” series. Anthony Trollope is also due a revival: Orley Farm and He Knew He Was Right would make cracking series. As would William Thackeray’s Pendennis – a story of making it in the big city – and Charlotte Brontë’s Villette, one of the most compelling novels of the 19th century. Moving into the 20th century, there is Elizabeth Bowen’s The Death of the Heart, Ivy Compton-Burnett’s Elders and Betters and Elizabeth Taylor’s The Soul of Kindness. Or how about Joseph Conrad’s Chance, an anti-capitalist seafaring adventure and the biggest success in his lifetime? What books would you like to see adapted for the small screen? Or are you happy with the BBC endlessly repeating Great Expectations and Sense and Sensibility? www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/feb/25/digested-week-greater-expectations-for-bbc-drama-but-not-nigel-farage
|
|
paislene
Junior Member
@paislene
Posts: 1,182
Likes: 510
|
Post by paislene on Feb 26, 2022 0:00:24 GMT
I'm in complete agreement , Carl ! It's getting confusing with the many adaptations of Great Expectations . Though , the Miss Havisham panegyric by Charles Dickens is just genius , Olivia Colman is a great actress , and if nothing else , there should be a full biographical expansion on the Havisham story , with Olivia as the adult version . I like all your ideas here , Carl , and the BBC should be doing those rather than just repeating another adaption of such well used and covered material .
|
|
|
Post by Feologild Oakes on Feb 26, 2022 1:55:39 GMT
There have been 19 movie and tv adaptions and 10 stage adaptions of Great Expectorations, it really does not need any more adaptions.
A Tale of Two Cities could use a new adaption the last one was in 1980 Or Our Mutual Friend which have only been adapted three times last in 1998.
Or Hard Times which as far as i know have only been adapted one time in 1915.
Or even Bleak House which have only been adapted four times last in 2005.
The only Dickens book that have been adapted more than Great Expectations is Oliver Twist. Which i think have been adapted to tv and movies 25 times.
You have 16 books to pick from and its petty much the same two books. They could pick one of the other 14 books to make an adaption from
I mean i think that Charles Dickens wrote 16 books.
|
|
|
Post by politicidal on Feb 28, 2022 0:46:22 GMT
They should change it up on occasion. I never read Nicholas Nickleby yet I enjoyed the 2002 movie.
|
|