|
Post by Popeye Doyle on Sept 2, 2024 23:29:58 GMT
Does the entire premise depend on people not questioning the lead character’s mental illness? The only one who does is Marla. Think of the scene at the tavern and two characters (one of who is imaginary) sharing a pitcher of beer. No one there questioning why someone is carrying on a full conversation with himself. Or the scene on the bus as well.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
@Deleted
Posts: 0
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 3, 2024 2:19:14 GMT
I always like the scene in the car because the two Space Monkeys look completely bewildered while Tyler has a full blown argument with himself before crashing it. I think, for them, they are taught to not ask questions and that anything Tyler does is a potential test.
Another scene where someone notices the two personalities is when Narrator talks to the police detective on the phone and Tyler comes in and out saying sarcastic stuff and the detective, who only hears the one voice, accuses Narrator of not taking the call seriously.
For a lot of other things, they cover their tracks with the explanation that sometimes Narrator pictures Tyler talking and vice versa, or Tyler speaking "for him" earlier.
|
|
|
Post by Popeye Doyle on Sept 3, 2024 2:25:07 GMT
I always like the scene in the car because the two Space Monkeys look completely bewildered while Tyler has a full blown argument with himself before crashing it. I think, for them, they are taught to not ask questions and that anything Tyler does is a potential test. Another scene where someone notices the two personalities is when Narrator talks to the police detective on the phone and Tyler comes in and out saying sarcastic stuff and the detective, who only hears the one voice, accuses Narrator of not taking the call seriously. For a lot of other things, they cover their tracks with the explanation that sometimes Narrator pictures Tyler talking and vice versa, or Tyler speaking "for him" earlier. Also important to never have Tyler, Marla, and American History X in the same shot.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
@Deleted
Posts: 0
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 3, 2024 2:31:01 GMT
I always like the scene in the car because the two Space Monkeys look completely bewildered while Tyler has a full blown argument with himself before crashing it. I think, for them, they are taught to not ask questions and that anything Tyler does is a potential test. Another scene where someone notices the two personalities is when Narrator talks to the police detective on the phone and Tyler comes in and out saying sarcastic stuff and the detective, who only hears the one voice, accuses Narrator of not taking the call seriously. For a lot of other things, they cover their tracks with the explanation that sometimes Narrator pictures Tyler talking and vice versa, or Tyler speaking "for him" earlier. Also important to never have Tyler, Marla, and American History X in the same shot. They technically are when Tyler answers the door with the glove while railing Marla. That's when Marla asks "who are you talking to?" In contrast is the scene where Marla and Narrator argue while "Tyler" is in the basement and Marla only apparently gets the Narrator.
|
|