|
|
Post by audiosane on Dec 16, 2017 21:41:31 GMT
But here's the thing. Can anyone name a good director they've picked so far? IMHO, all these guys are mediocre to competent at best. Nothing special. I'm not talking about the replacement directors, like Ron Howard. I still think the choice of director should largely be utterly irrelevant, e.g. I have absolutely no problem with JJ's actual directing job on TFA - it looked great, authentic old school Star Wars. What should have been completely relevant though - especially once they decided to give George Lucas the bullet - was getting a hugely competent, respected writer onboard who really was a huge Star Wars fan (beyond the obligatory "big fan" soundbites they've all made) to, at minimum, outline the story of the entire trilogy, what the start / end points of each episide had to be, with anything that needed to be revealed inbetween, making sure the whole thing tied in with, and respected, the rest of the Saga.   |
|
|
|
Post by coldenhaulfield on Dec 16, 2017 23:52:21 GMT
I still think the choice of director should largely be utterly irrelevant, e.g. I have absolutely no problem with JJ's actual directing job on TFA - it looked great, authentic old school Star Wars. What should have been completely relevant though - especially once they decided to give George Lucas the bullet - was getting a hugely competent, respected writer onboard who really was a huge Star Wars fan (beyond the obligatory "big fan" soundbites they've all made) to, at minimum, outline the story of the entire trilogy, what the start / end points of each episide had to be, with anything that needed to be revealed inbetween, making sure the whole thing tied in with, and respected, the rest of the Saga. The bill is finally coming due on their hotshot approach to Star Wars. |
|
pete8680
Sophomore
Yo!
@pete8680
Posts: 464
Likes: 448
 
|
Post by pete8680 on Dec 17, 2017 4:03:41 GMT
The directing was good. Everybody was acting better but.....
THE STORY WAS FACKING GARBAGE. RJ & KK CAN GO EAT A BAG OF ELEPHANT D!CKS. THE PREQULS ARE DIVINE COMPAIRED TO THIS HORSE SH!T. NOW I KNOW HOW YOU PT HATERS FEEL. IM DONE WITH THIS CUCKING TRILOGY.
Bring on Solo. Sigh.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
@Deleted
Posts: 0
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 17, 2017 22:13:34 GMT
The directing was good. Everybody was acting better but..... THE STORY WAS FACKING GARBAGE. RJ & KK CAN GO EAT A BAG OF ELEPHANT D!CKS. THE PREQULS ARE DIVINE COMPAIRED TO THIS HORSE SH!T. NOW I KNOW HOW YOU PT HATERS FEEL. IM DONE WITH THIS CUCKING TRILOGY. Bring on Solo. Sigh. Exactly this. I've had no problem with the technical direction. It was the story. The story was written by someone who despises Star Wars. That is the only explanation. Even an idiot who knew nothing about Star Wars could've thrown darts at potential story lines and gotten a better result. This was so bad it seemed intentional. |
|
