Which of these would beat up all the rest in their prime?

My money would be on Bruce Lee.

Bruce Lee

Bruce Lee and Sly Stallone could take all those other guys single-handedly.

Taking a quick look online (between Bing/Google) it shows the following for each height/weight (ill list them from overall biggest to smallest)...

Arnold = 6'2" @ 249lbs
Steven Seagal = 6'4" @ 225lbs
JCVD = 5'10" @ 176-185lbs
Chuck Norris = 5'8"-5'10" @ 154-170lbs
Bruce Lee = 5'7" @ 130-160lbs


so with the above info as a general guideline for their height/size, ill say this...

I would lean towards Bruce Lee or Chuck Norris as the winner (I voted for Chuck Norris since he has less votes and those with fighting experience are likely to take out those without fight experience in general which is why I think it boils down to Lee/Norris for this topic) with a chance for Arnold because of his sheer size as he seems to have roughly 100+ pounds on Norris/Lee which has to count for something but only if he can get into a situation where he can use it. also, depending on Bruce Lee's weight, whether it's closer to 130lbs or 160lbs, I suspect Lee's advantage is his raw speed but if he's really 160lbs I suspect that's going to make a rather big difference in his overall power vs if he was closer to 130lbs or so. but from what I can tell, earlier on he was probably about 130lbs or so but later on was probably the 160lbs range as you can tell from looking at some of his earlier footage he seemed not as fit as say the Enter the Dragon (1973) days etc.


but I have to add this... it seems Bruce Lee has this built-up image like he's untouchable so I am not surprised he's winning the poll based on that alone. but I have a feeling he would not do as well as his image is built up to be in real fights in general especially given his smaller size(although 130lbs to 160lbs would be a solid difference I suspect in his overall power especially considered he looked like he was in very good shape and very toned). like in his own weight class I would imagine he would probably excel (especially nowadays where UFC has evolved quite a bit) but being most guys are over his weight that's got to put him at a disadvantage on some level especially when his opponent is in decent shape and has solid fighting experience. I would imagine his ability to win will probably boil down to whether his speed can overtake others brute force, especially if his weight is closer to 130lbs vs 160lbs because at 130lbs that's got to be a clear disadvantage but if he was really 160lbs I suspect his chances of winning go up quite a bit because now he's got a bit of power behind his raw speed. but then again if you get some of those UFC guys (I know this is not the debate of this topic but Ill just mention it a bit) who might be say 6'+ @ 200lbs+ that's got to make Lee's chances of winning decline quite a bit (but seems like Lee is pretty much one of those fighters who was 'ahead of his time' but UFC has evolved quite a bit in the last 20-25 years or so). also, some footage I was watching of Bruce Lee online a moment ago, which seems to be more legitimate sparing footage of him, looks like he was about 135lbs at the time of that footage which is this... www.thegoodsurvivalist.com/who-would-win-in-a-real-fight-bruce-lee-vs-chuck-norris/

but at the end of the day... even someone with a pretty solid size advantage does not automatically mean they could take someone who's in good shape, with decent fighting experience, even if they are noticeably smaller. but with that said... it would be interesting if The Rock was in the topic to as he's got solid sheer size and seems fast enough to where I can't see to many people taking him out straight up in a real fight.

just some thoughts ; but I guess these scenarios are always cool to think about once in a while.