|
Post by Agent of Chaos on May 5, 2018 19:44:10 GMT
No, Steve has his a magnetic gauntlet he uses to hold his shield. Which he also used in the comics. ![](https://i.imgur.com/BNzHlKF.gif) ![](https://i.imgur.com/DJ7dW69.jpg) It was shown in Age of Ultron, not Winter Soldier. My mistake. If you look at that clip, it's always the shield's center that attaches to Cap's arm, meaning it's only that center underside part that's magnetic. If the entire shield was magnetic then the shield would attach to Cap's arm in a whole host of different ways, not always the same. So in the end, this is still not proof that vibranium itself is magnetic. No, Steve has his a magnetic gauntlet he uses to hold his shield. Which he also used in the comics. ![](https://i.imgur.com/BNzHlKF.gif) ![](https://i.imgur.com/DJ7dW69.jpg) It was shown in Age of Ultron, not Winter Soldier. My mistake. Figured you may mention that but as Skaathar said it's only the centre part of the shield where the arm holster is that seems magnetic, that implies that either that has a specific device that's connected to Cap's wrist gauntlet thing and his back holster or has a simply lining of ferrous metal for the magnets on his wrist and back to hold onto, as Skaathar said if the shield was as a whole effected by magnets it wouldn't only be that area that's ever effected, also this is in Winter Soldier also so you were correct in that, but as I said if the shield was influenced by magnets the magnetic cuffs they tried to use on Cap in the elevator scene would also be drawn onto it which they aren't.Silly argument. The shield returned like that in the comics as well and vibranium has been shown in the books to be magnetic. They were just emulating the books. You’re putting way too much thought into this. EDIT: There were a bunch of metal objects I’m the elevator those magnets didn’t influenced. Like the stuff they used to shock Cap.
|
|
|
Post by dazz on May 5, 2018 20:15:53 GMT
If you look at that clip, it's always the shield's center that attaches to Cap's arm, meaning it's only that center underside part that's magnetic. If the entire shield was magnetic then the shield would attach to Cap's arm in a whole host of different ways, not always the same. So in the end, this is still not proof that vibranium itself is magnetic. Figured you may mention that but as Skaathar said it's only the centre part of the shield where the arm holster is that seems magnetic, that implies that either that has a specific device that's connected to Cap's wrist gauntlet thing and his back holster or has a simply lining of ferrous metal for the magnets on his wrist and back to hold onto, as Skaathar said if the shield was as a whole effected by magnets it wouldn't only be that area that's ever effected, also this is in Winter Soldier also so you were correct in that, but as I said if the shield was influenced by magnets the magnetic cuffs they tried to use on Cap in the elevator scene would also be drawn onto it which they aren't.Silly argument. The shield returned like that in the comics as well and vibranium has been shown in the books to be magnetic. They were just emulating the books. You’re putting way too much thought into this. EDIT: There were a bunch of metal objects I’m the elevator those magnets didn’t influenced. Like the stuff they used to shock Cap. In the comics the shield isn't pure vibranium but a vibranium iron blend, that's why it's magnetic there, in the MCU it's pure vibranium, and I'm not talking about the cuffs pulling shit in but when Steve uses the shield to break one off of his wrist if the vibranium was magnetic then the cuff should have attached to the shield which it didn't.
Also you don't know what certain things are made of they could be made of non magnetic material, not all metals are magnetic after all.
|
|
|
Post by Agent of Chaos on May 5, 2018 20:39:01 GMT
Silly argument. The shield returned like that in the comics as well and vibranium has been shown in the books to be magnetic. They were just emulating the books. You’re putting way too much thought into this. EDIT: There were a bunch of metal objects I’m the elevator those magnets didn’t influenced. Like the stuff they used to shock Cap. In the comics the shield isn't pure vibranium but a vibranium iron blend, that's why it's magnetic there, in the MCU it's pure vibranium, and I'm not talking about the cuffs pulling shit in but when Steve uses the shield to break one off of his wrist if the vibranium was magnetic then the cuff should have attached to the shield which it didn't.
Also you don't know what certain things are made of they could be made of non magnetic material, not all metals are magnetic after all.
What issue said that Cap’s shield was blended with iron? It only says that on Wikipedia without a reference. Even if that were true that doesn’t make the way the shield attaches to the magnetic gauntlet a valid argument.
|
|
|
Post by dazz on May 5, 2018 23:13:04 GMT
In the comics the shield isn't pure vibranium but a vibranium iron blend, that's why it's magnetic there, in the MCU it's pure vibranium, and I'm not talking about the cuffs pulling shit in but when Steve uses the shield to break one off of his wrist if the vibranium was magnetic then the cuff should have attached to the shield which it didn't.
Also you don't know what certain things are made of they could be made of non magnetic material, not all metals are magnetic after all.
What issue said that Cap’s shield was blended with iron? It only says that on Wikipedia without a reference. Even if that were true that doesn’t make the way the shield attaches to the magnetic gauntlet a valid argument. This Link has an explanation to what Cap's shield is made of, in it it's a blend of vibranium and steel alloy though, but still that's a ferrous metal to explain the magnetic effects on it, the comics also say that Cap's shield has tech upgrades such as magnets and stuff steve can control thanks to Tony, but Cap supposedly discards them, but this could be why he can summon it the way he can still, I dunno but the comics do state vibranium naturally is not effected by magnetism or Magneto, the films show magnets not working on the shield in any way but at the harness area specifically.
Also really dumb argument given except for BP I even conceded Magneto could destroy Ultron or Vision if they have parts made of ferrous metals anyway, and that due to whatever magnetic part of the shield comes from Magneto could still use that against Cap anyway, only thing is pointing out vibranium and there by BP would not be subject to Magneto's powers.
|
|
|
Post by lenlenlen1 on May 7, 2018 15:25:39 GMT
With Phoenix at full power they certainly stand a chance. Professor X and Magneto might be able to get some licks in too, maybe. But that's the the thing? Jean from Apocalypse 35 years older or Jean from X3? I'm willing to bet the reality stone is more powerful than their telepathy. Phoenix is just an omega class mutant. She's not the cosmic entity in the movies. Even if she was the cosmic entity like in the comics, is she more powerful than the Infinity stones? Well I said they stand a chance, not that they would win for sure. Also I said Jean at full power. We'll see what she looks like in the Dark Phoenix movie.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
@Deleted
Posts: 0
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on May 7, 2018 22:30:43 GMT
tell him to calm down and accept others subjective opinion He needs to learn that these are just movies and there is no reason to get so aggressive over them. Tell that to MCU fans. MCU fans constantly get aggressive over a bunch of shitty movies. I don't care who gets aggressive over what. Also not all MCU fans get aggressive and shitty is merely subjective. If summers8 is going to be this aggressive then I will call him out on it regardless on whether it's for the MCU, X Men movies and DCEU.
|
|