(
continued from last post)
Whew--yes, I do write a lot!
So, movies like DePalma's
Dressed to Kill and
Sisters replicate only the trappings of a Hitchcock movie (the elaborate scores; the "Hitchcock blonde" [yes, I know Miss Kidder isn't a blonde, but the point still holds]; the plotting mechanics borrowed from, in both of these cases,
Psycho; the throwing of an innocent into a shocking world) and not the true essence of one.
Now, that's not a strike against these movies--in fact, I'm a huge fan of DePalma, especially
Dressed to Kill. It is, however, a misconception that, in my opinion, needs pointing out. (Another example is Robert Zemeckis's hugely enjoyable
What Lies Beneath, which did not deserve the critical panning it received. Like the DePalma works, it doesn't imitate AH at any more than the most superficial level, but--also like them--it's a great deal of fun [the twists are particularly clever].)
It's also, by the way, why I don't find
Charade all that Hitchcockian, though it's still a great deal of fun. (Oh, and Hitchcock would have never used the "dying clue" aspect in the plot, which I, with my fondness for puzzle plotting, quite like.) I didn't much like
Arabesque, though, unfortunately.
What would I put in their place as "Hitchcockian movies," then? (Because, unlike @gottaluvafriend , I do think there
are a few movies that come off as
truly Hitchcockian.)
David Fincher's brilliant
Panic Room, which also cares more about its characters than its plot, is the first modern picture that comes to mind, definitely. (I've written more about it
here.)
Also Kenneth Branagh's
Jack Ryan: Shadow Recruit, one of the best popcorn movies to come out in recent years (and, of course, little-remembered only a few short years later).
As for classics...
Night Train to Munich, which I've highlighted
elsewhere on this forum, has pointed differences from Hitch's
The Lady Vanishes (I actually prefer
Night Train), but Carol Reed's direction is undoubtedly inspired by the Master's. (It's available for
free on YouTube, albeit not in a particularly good print.)
Seven Sinners (1936), a little-known favorite of mine, feels like one of Hitch's 30s British thrillers. (It's also currently available for
free on YouTube.)
I'm sure I'll think of more, but that's a good list for now, right?
EDIT: I've thought of another, Polanski's
Frantic. For me, the most wholly satisfying picture in Polanski's largely unsatisfying
oeuvre. (I should point out I haven't seen
Chinatown--what! I know, I know, will get on it some time soon.) It's an excellent picture that captures Hitchcock in
both superficiality and deeper meaning--and, if
Frenzy is any indication, is exactly the kind of movie that Hitchcock would have been making if he'd still been alive in '88.
Dead Calm is certainly Hitchcockian. I didn't think of it at first because I thought it slightly overrated, but it's a still a fine movie, with grand central performances from Nicole Kidman and Billy Zane in particular.
Oh, and how could I forget
From Russia with Love, which borrows a whole sequence from
North by Northwest? (Yes, that fact
is a superficiality by my definition, but bear with me.) The emphasis is on suspense far more than surprise, in the Hitchcockian manner, and Bond, while a spy, is involved similarly to one of Hitch's innocents. The best of the Bonds, with
Goldfinger as the steepest competition.
I don't know whether to put
Unknown ('11) on here because, while in some ways it is far more Hitchcockian than most modern thrillers (e.g., it has a potential end-twist that the director/writer decides to explode before the ending, heightening suspense rather than surprise, and features a very Hitchcockian ice blonde in January Jones's character), it is shot in a very modern, non-Hitchcockian way. A strange dichotomy, that. Either way, I think it's a great movie. Bruno Ganz, in particular, is a delight in it.
And here's another one!
Double Jeopardy ('99) is, with
Panic Room and
Frantic, the most Hitchcockian modern film I've seen. Illogical? Absolutely. But it is purely Hitchcockian, unlike most modern thrillers, and sheer fun.